What are the opening hours?

Monday 10am - 5pm Tuesday 10am - 5pm Wednesday 10am - 5pm Thursday 10am - 5pm Friday 10am - 5pm Saturday 10am - 3pm

Blue Butterfly Thrift Store - Oconomowoc

Home
United States
Oconomowoc, WI
Blue Butterfly Thrift Store - Oconomowoc

Call Directions Website Contact the organization

Blue Butterfly Thrift Store strives to repurpose lightly used clothing, small furniture, and house-ware products through our faith-based retail store.

Blue Butterfly is a volunteer-based thrift store to support organizations that are focused on faithfully serving others, providing resources to those in need and sharing God's love from conception to eternity. Our mission is for residents of Oconomowoc and the surrounding areas to have access to good quality, affordable products, in a clean, comfortable, Christian atmosphere. Profits that are generated from these sales are given to Alpha Resource Center, Christian Family Solutions (WLCFS) and Tomorrow’s Choice, working together to support primary ministry areas that relate to the sanctity of life, mental health counseling, and senior care services.

10/29/2026

CONGRATULATIONS TO OUR WORLD SERIES CHAMPIONS-THE MILWAUKEE BREWERS🎉🎉🎉🥳🥳🥳🥳🎈🎈🎈🎈🎈🎊
Come in today to shop our kitchen sale-50% off all kitchen items
Yellow tags 50 cents

10/28/2026

The kitchen sale is in full swing here at The Blue Butterfly🥄🥣🧫 It’s 50% off kitchen through Saturday!
While you’re in-check out our 50 cent yellow tags!!! Stock up on great deals!!!

10/27/2026

This weeks is the big kitchen sale at Blue Butterfly!!!! Make sure you get all of your serve ware for your Brewers watch parties!!!!
We also have yellow tags at .50🎉🥳🎈🎊

10/24/2026

Y’all-with all these Brewers wins, it’s feeling like Christmas morning when you’re a child and keep opening gift after gift!!!🎄🤶🏻🧑‍🎄 To be honest , our little thrift store looks a lot like Christmas right now too!!! Come on in and shop our Christmas selection while you can-it seems to be flying out the door as fast as we put it out! While you’re celebrating all of your wins-make sure you check out all of our sales! We’ve got 50% off women’s athletic wear
50% off pictures and frames

10/23/2026

While you are eagerly waiting for the first game of The World Series to start tonight-get your thrift on to ease your nerves!!! We have so many great deals from our half off pictures and frames to our half off women’s athletic wear(excluding white tags)! While you’re here, grab some fun glow sticks to take to your Brewers watch party!!!!

10/22/2026

Today’s focus is on our stellar volunteers that we have at the Blue Butterfly! The great people that volunteer not only their time but their gifts and talents- from organizing to decorating to sorting and sifting, to pricing items and keeping this thrift store running like a well oiled machine and helping in any way they possible can! Our volunteers are the life’s blood of our organization and we couldn’t do it without them🫶🏼 They were here for hours last night getting the store cleaned up and reset for today’s opening! Come in and see what they were working on🎄🤶🏻🧑‍🎄

10/21/2026

Happy Hump day - Wednesday at our Butterfly Thrift Stores – Oconomowoc and Watertown

Discover great finds at Blue Butterfly Thrift Stores!

Our volunteers do a wonderful job of making sure the items we offer are clean, carefully inspected, and ready for a new home.

We still have 90% off on Halloween items!

50% off Pictures and Frames - we have some great art work!

We also have long-sleeve and short sleeve shirts for ONLY $2.50

and sweaters for ONLY $3.50!

The linen departments are full of great finds.
Check out the quality pillows, towels, place settings, sleeping bags, blankets, and other household linens.

Looking for winter gear? We have some great winter jackets and sporting goods coming out, especially skis as we get ready for the Wisconsin winter season.

Have Pets? Stop by our pet section for some great deals on items for your pets.

Working on your man cave, garage, or next project? Our man cave section features tools and hardware that are constantly being rotated, so there’s always a reason to check back.

Hunters will also want to explore our hunting section for some great finds.

And Christmas is on! We have tons of Christmas items coming out on the sales floor, and they’re selling quickly.

Come early and come often, because you never know what you might find on your next visit.

Blue Butterfly is about much more than thrift shopping. We are deeply grateful for our customers, donors, and volunteers who make our ministry possible. At our recent gala dinner, we shared more about the people we serve and the difference this ministry makes in our communities. From moms and families who need help caring for their children to individuals facing mental health challenges, addiction, or homelessness, your support helps us reach people who need a helping hand.

We continue giving back to our local communities, including supporting schools, police, fire departments, and others who serve our neighbors.

When you shop at Blue Butterfly, you’re not just finding great items at great prices. You’re helping make a difference in the lives of people right here in our communities.

Thank you for being part of the Blue Butterfly family. We appreciate you more than you know, and we look forward to seeing you soon!

Blue Butterfly Thrift Stores

Oconomowoc 1165 Summit Ave. Oconomowoc, WI

Watertown 2 East Main St. Watertown, WI

10/20/2026

This weeks sales are as follows: Women’s activewear is 50% off all week!
Whatever is remaining of our Halloween is 90% off
Women’s dresses and pants are $2.00 (excluding jeans and white tags)
We are constantly in taking donations so our inventory is always changing which makes thrifting so much more enjoyable!!!!

10/19/2026

Let’s keep winning Wisconsin! With The Brewers headed to the World Series and the Packers victory last night-you all need to celebrate and come in to The Blue Butterfly to buy all of your hosting items for the parties!!! We are open 10-5 Monday through Friday so make sure you stop in for your thrifting win!!!!!
This week we have pictures and frames at 50% off

10/17/2026

Super Saturday Deals and Steals at our Butterfly Thrift Stores – Oconomowoc and Watertown

There’s always something new to discover at Blue Butterfly Thrift Stores, and our volunteers do a wonderful job of making sure the items we offer are clean, carefully inspected, and ready for a new home.

90% off on Halloween items!

We also have long-sleeve and short sleeve shirts for ONLY $2.50

and sweaters for ONLY $3.50!

Our linen departments are full of great finds. We have incredible volunteers that do an excellent job organizing and checking everything, including quality pillows, towels, place settings, sleeping bags, blankets, and other household linens.

Looking for winter gear? We have some great winter jackets and sporting goods coming out, especially skis as we get ready for the Wisconsin winter season.

Have Pets? Stop by our pet section for some great deals on items for your pets.

Working on your man cave, garage, or next project? Our man cave section features tools and hardware that are constantly being rotated, so there’s always a reason to check back.

Hunters will also want to explore our hunting section for some great finds.

And Christmas is on! We have many Christmas items out on the sales floor, and they’re selling quickly.

Come early and come often, because you never know what you might find on your next visit.

Blue Butterfly is about much more than thrift shopping. We are deeply grateful for our customers, donors, and volunteers who make our ministry possible. At our recent gala dinner, we shared more about the people we serve and the difference this ministry makes in our communities. From moms and families who need help caring for their children to individuals facing mental health challenges, addiction, or homelessness, your support helps us reach people who need a helping hand.

We continue giving back to our local communities, including supporting schools, police, fire departments, and others who serve our neighbors.

When you shop at Blue Butterfly, you’re not just finding great items at great prices. You’re helping make a difference in the lives of people right here in our communities.

Thank you for being part of the Blue Butterfly family. We appreciate you more than you know, and we look forward to seeing you soon!

Blue Butterfly Thrift Stores

Oconomowoc 1165 Summit Ave. Oconomowoc, WI

Watertown 2 East Main St. Watertown, WI

Address

1165 Summit Avenue
Oconomowoc, WI
53066

Opening Hours

Monday	10am - 5pm
Tuesday	10am - 5pm
Wednesday	10am - 5pm
Thursday	10am - 5pm
Friday	10am - 5pm
Saturday	10am - 3pm

Telephone

+12622074889

Website

http://bluebutterflythrift.org/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Blue Butterfly Thrift Store - Oconomowoc posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.