08/26/2026
A recording has surfaced from a private meeting of Whittier's city manager, and it's raising new questions about who's shaping the city's tree policy.
On Aug. 17, Conal McNamara told a room of business leaders that the entire fight over Whittier's trees comes down to one word: "healthy."
Here's the conflict: the Conservancy can sue over any "healthy" tree the city wants to call hazardous. Redefine that one word, McNamara says, and the lawsuit threats go away.
This was a foundational meeting for a new tree plan, called the Urban Forest Management Plan (UFMP), being written by the city's consultants.
The consultants' contract says community survey questions will be "carefully framed" around "public safety, risk management, and the necessity of tree removal rather than aesthetics or personal preferences."
Given the recording, we asked the city manager whether the outcome is already predetermined, despite planned community outreach. He didn't respond.
The city is spending over $800k to create the UFMP.
The city already has community meetings scheduled, with first one only 3 weeks away, with no sign of promotion so far:
District 4: Sept. 17, 6 p.m., Ocean View Elementary
District 1: Sept. 29, 6 p.m., Evergreen Elementary
District 3: Sept. 30, 6 p.m., Whittwood Branch Library
District 2: Oct. 1, 6 p.m., Palm Park
Full story in comments.