10/15/2026
They crowned the girl who raised the most money. That was the rule at the Red Rose Cotillion, a debutante ball that a club of Black women in Tacoma, Washington, built for their own girls. The woman behind it, Dorothy Mason Brown, was the daughter of a domestic worker and the granddaughter of a farm wife. So how does a woman like that end up running a debutante ball?
Dorothy started with a beauty shop under her own house.
She had come to Washington State from Texas as an army wife, with a husband stationed at Fort Lewis, just south of Tacoma. Once the family settled in the city for good, he turned the old apartment beneath their home into a salon. They named it Dot's House of Beauty.
Women came down there to get their hair done, and they came to talk. If somebody in your family ever did hair at home, you already know what kind of room this was.
"It was a bit like a community center," her daughter Betty said, "because the ladies would come to talk about their problems."
In February 1963, Dorothy and fourteen other women started the Unique Social and Community Club. The club put its support behind the NAACP, the civil rights group, along with several churches and scholarships for young people. Then, in 1966, it gave its first ball.
A debutante ball, also called a cotillion, is a formal night where families present their daughters to the community as young women. The club held its cotillion in the Crystal Ballroom of the Winthrop Hotel, the big hotel in downtown Tacoma, open since 1925.
The girls had to earn their place in that room.
Each debutante took charm and dance lessons, did community service, and sold ads to local businesses for the souvenir booklet. That last part means a teenage girl walking into a neighborhood shop and asking the owner to buy an ad. I did not expect a debutante ball to come with a sales job.
When a girl was finally presented, the room heard what she had done. Betty said the introduction "was letting the audience know the kinds of things that you had done."
By the fall of 1968 the ball was heading into its third year, and the club women did something for themselves. On October 8, twelve of them went to a photographer's studio in evening gowns and gloves that reached the elbow.
Seven stood and five sat. The Tacoma Public Library keeps that photograph now, and its record says who ordered it: the club.
Whoever wrote that record also wrote down who was in the picture, left to right.
Dorothy is one of the five seated. Standing fifth from the left is Frances Wilkenson, who sewed for a living. That is a beautician and a seamstress in gloves to the elbow.
About ten weeks later, on December 20, the hotel ballroom filled with family and friends. Thirty young women in white gowns stood under the chandelier, each holding long-stemmed red roses, the kind called American Beauty.
Their escorts wore white gloves. Two days later the News Tribune, Tacoma's daily paper, printed all thirty names.
The library's record of that night calls the girls collegians, meaning college students. I like that word better than debutante.
The girl crowned queen that night was Dorothy's daughter Betty, who is Dr. Betty Cobbs today. At that ball a queen earned her crown, and it came with a college scholarship. "It was a source of pride, also for the families, because you were representing your family up there," Betty said.
Then the women lost their ballroom.
In the fall of 1971, the Winthrop closed as a hotel. So where do you hold a debutante ball when the big hotel shuts its doors?
The club moved theirs into the old Elks Temple on Broadway.
If you don't know the Elks, they are a men's lodge with chapters all over the country. They put up that temple in 1916. By 1971 the Elks had moved out, and the place was rented for events.
For as long as the Elks ran that building, a Black man could not join, because their national rules said so. Black men in Tacoma had started their own club in 1957, and its founders mortgaged their homes to buy it a clubhouse. One founder's niece said they did it "because there was nowhere for Black men to go."
The Elks rule was still standing in December 1971, when the women brought their ball inside.
On December 30, eight of the club women posed for a photograph there, under an arch of evergreen. The historians who work for the building's current owners have a name for those women holding their ball in that hall. They call it poetic justice.
The Red Rose Cotillion stayed a December tradition into the middle of the 1970s.
By 1975, Frances Wilkenson, the club's seamstress, had a granddaughter old enough to be presented. The granddaughter's name is Crystal Wright, and she had been at every one of those balls since she was ten.
At ten Crystal was the coat check girl, and she made sashes too. "I couldn't wait to not be ten," Crystal said.
At home, Frances had the girl walk the living room with a book on her head.
The grown folks around that child expected a lot. Crystal said "that was a time when, if you did something wrong, somebody called your mother."
When Crystal's own year came, Frances did not hand the girl a dress. "She gave us bridal magazines and told us to find the dress that we liked," Crystal said.
Then Frances designed and sewed the gowns herself, one for Crystal and more for Crystal's friends. That is a white gown out of a magazine picture, made by your own grandmother.
Crystal had invited a classmate to be presented with her, and the classmate said years later that being asked "truly was like a lifeline for me."
They started getting ready at least six months ahead, and Frances found a choreographer to run the rehearsals. The girls practiced how to stop, pose, wait and curtsy, with every move timed.
Crystal brought a young man she had met at a church conference. "I wanted to take him because he had the biggest, coolest Afro," Crystal said.
That December, at Crystal's ball, the debutantes carried red roses and white chrysanthemums the News Tribune called snowballs. They danced an old-fashioned dance with parasols. On cotillion nights, dinner, ch*****ne toasts from the parents and a father and daughter waltz rounded out the evening.
Dorothy chaired the ball that year, and she told the News Tribune what it was for. "Our goal is to introduce a charming and graceful young woman who has worked hard toward goals of cultural development, refinement, responsibility and a more productive way of life," Dorothy said.
Crystal has a plainer way to say what the women pulled off.
"You would have thought we were rich," Crystal said. "I did not know we did not have money until I got ready to go to college."
That feeling is not an accident. Grown women built it for Crystal, one fitting and one rehearsal at a time.
Crystal did get to college. She went to Seattle University, and the classmate she had invited went to the University of Washington.
After 1975, the women eventually retired the Red Rose Cotillion, and the record I could reach does not give the year. The club itself kept at its work for more than twenty years in all.
Dorothy worked as a classroom aide in Tacoma's schools, went back to college herself, and earned a bachelor's degree in her later years. At 74 Dorothy was thinking about going back again, this time to become a psychologist. "She was a do-er, a helper, a supporter," Betty said.
The old Elks Temple is a hotel today. One of its guest rooms is dedicated to Dorothy Mason Brown, and a painting of her is displayed there. The building that had no place for her people now keeps a room in her name.
The women beside Dorothy in that 1968 portrait have a caption, and it kept every one of their names. All twelve are at the bottom of this post, spelled as the record spells them, for anybody who wants to say them out loud.
Crystal can tell you what she carried out of that night along with the magazine dress. "I really felt like someone had just given us the secret to fabulousness," she said.
I put a lot of effort into researching and sharing stories that matter.
If you'd like to support the work, here's the link:
https://ko-fi.com/blackhistorystories
Every coffee helps me keep creating.
