10/24/2026
37 years ago today, Benita "Nita" Moore Spears vanished from Gary, Indiana. 💔
At 23, Benita was a mom of two little boys, attending college full-time at IU Northwest, and worked as a clerical worker at Inland Steel in East Chicago.
Her mother talked to her the day before she disappeared and said she seemed fine. Friends reported that Benita was reported to be in cheerful spirits the night before.
But Benita had been physically abused by her ex-husband, Johnnie Lee Spears Jr. In 1988, he pleaded guilty to criminally confining her and was sentenced to two years.
He was released from jail on October 24, 1989.
That same day, Benita was seen with Johnny in her car. It is the last time she was ever seen.
The next day, her mother went to Benita's home on E. 19th Ave. and found the car parked outside. Police questioned Johnnie and released him. He refused to take a polygraph test. Afterward, he was seen driving Benita's car — before the car itself went missing. It was recovered a month later, on November 29, 1989, abandoned at a South Shore Line parking lot in East Chicago.
No charges have ever been filed in Benita's disappearance.
Benita would be 60 years old today. She deserves to be found. 37 years is too long. 🙏
Please share this post. If you know anything, please submit a tip to Gary PD at (219) 881-7300, comment below, or send us a message.