01/27/2026
SDHS Ordered to Pay More Than $500,000 for Violating Animal Cruelty Laws
On October 24, 2025, the Court heard Pet Assistance Foundation (PAF)âs motion for attorneysâ fees following its successful case against the San Diego Humane Society (SDHS) for violations of Californiaâs animal cruelty laws.
The dispute concerned SDHSâs practice of abandoning healthy, friendly, adoptable cats brought to the shelter by the public unless staff determined there was âverifiable proof of ownership,â such as the animal being found in a box. The Court found this standard unreasonably high, issued a permanent injunction prohibiting its use, and imposed further restrictions to prevent SDHS from turning away stray and abandoned cats and kittens at the door.
Although the Pease & Ijadi firm represented PAF on a pro bono basis, Californiaâs private attorney general statute requires defendants to pay market-rate attorneysâ fees when litigation confers a significant public benefit. The Court found that standard met here.
In a statement to the Court, a representative of PAF explained:
âI am no longer being contacted by distraught and grieving pet owners whose lost cats were denied legal holding periods and quickly and illegally euthanized or subjected to exploratory surgery, ear disfigurement, and abandonment by SDHS. Further, I am hearing that more kittens aged 3â6 months are now being given a genuine chance at a proper home than SDHS had previously been willing to provide.â
While SDHS argued that no public benefit was achieved, the Court disagreed and awarded full attorneysâ fees for more than four and a half years of litigation. This ruling ensures that future public-interest cases can be brought to hold agencies and nonprofits accountable when they violate animal protection laws. Bryan Pease NOAH - Not One Animal Harmed Social Compassion in Legislation Paw Protectors Rescue ALMA - Animal Lives Matter.Always Justice For 318 Fix Our Shelters Lucky Pup Dog Rescue. Changing Lives, One Little Dog At A
Erin Riley-Carrasco ARF Harbor Shelter San Diego, CA â Lost Dogs, Cats & Pets â PawBoost CommunityInland Empire Animal Coalition Animals Rule Placement Foundation
https://petassistancefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/mobileheader.jpg