10/02/2026
On October 2, 1780, British Major John André was hanged as a spy by the Continental Army. André had been negotiating with disillusioned American General Benedict Arnold, who was then serving as the Commandant of West Point, to surrender the base for £20,000. Had it succeeded, the Hudson River might have been taken and New England would have been cut off from the rest of the colonies.
André found himself isolated after the British sloop-of-war Vulture was driven off by artillery fire while he was conferring with Arnold at the Joshua Hett Smith House (Treason House) in West Haverstraw, New York. Donning civilian clothes provided by Arnold, André set off to return to British lines with six papers hidden in his stockings as well as a signed pass from Arnold.
Setting out on the morning of September 23, he was captured near Tarrytown, NY by a group that has been described as militia units but that deserves more analysis. Parts of Westchester County were operated by highway men groups called the Skinners and Cowboys. Their allegiance to either side was tenuous at best and more so dependent on payoffs.
When Andre came into contact with three men who stopped him, his initial thought was that they were Tories as one of them wore the coat of a Hessian soldier. Andre called out, “ Gentlemen, "I hope you belong to our party." "What party?" asked one of the men. "The lower party," replied André, meaning the British. "We do," was the answer. André then told them that he was a British officer who must not be detained, when, to his surprise, they said that they were Continentals, and that he was their prisoner. He then told them that he was a U.S. officer and showed them his pass signed by Arnold, but the suspicions of his captors were now aroused. They searched him and found Arnold's papers in his stocking. Only one of the men could read and Arnold was not initially suspected. André offered them his horse and watch, if they would let him go, but they declined. André testified at his trial that the men searched his boots for the purpose of robbing him. At this point they realized that he was a spy and took him to Continental Army headquarters in Sand's Hill in modern Armonk on the CT border.
André was found guilty and sentenced to be hanged for operating as a spy behind enemy lines. Had he wore his uniform the sentence would have been imprisonment. Most of the jailers found themselves endeared to André as a he was a charming, good looking young man of 29 years.
Further reading:
The Arnold/Andre Story: Ten Days that Shook Our Coutnry. https://www.hudsonrivervalley.org/.../34027eeb-a4e9-4077...
James Thacher. Military Journal of the American Revolution. https://archive.org/details/thacherjamesmil00revorich
Image: The Unfortunate Death of Major John Andre by John Goldar. 1 January 1783