10/15/2026
My Apology
The Living Genjō Kōan
October 11–12, 2026
The Record of Genpo — Genpo Roshi
So I sat, and I sat once again.
It’s been very, very humbling.
I can see how I went to war with my Zen Master, Maezumi Roshi.
I owe a deep apology to the entire Buddhist world, to both the living Patriarchs and the deceased Ancestors as well, Dogen Zenji and all the masters that preceded us.
I owe the whole planet an apology.
I have undermined faith and trust in the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.
And I want to set the record straight.
Not for my reputation. Not because I expect anyone to forgive me, change their mind about me, or welcome me back into anything.
I am eighty-two years old. I have practiced Zen for fifty-five years. What matters to me now is the Dharma, The Truth.
I want to leave a record of what this practice actually looks like when it is lived by a human being. Not an idealized Zen Master. Not a perfect Buddha. A human being willing to expose everything—his awakening, his shadows, his abuses of power, his contradictions, his suffering, his joy, and his continuing realization.
Nothing concealed. Nothing excused. Nothing falsified.
Leaving My Teacher
On June 4, 1984, after twelve years at the Zen Center of Los Angeles, I drove away with my wife, Brenda Hobai Liu, our two-year-old son, Tai, and our good friend Jan Chozen Bays, who so kindly drove us LAX.
As soon as we were out of the driveway, I yelled:
“Yippee! I escaped with my spirit intact!”
I meant it.
I felt liberated. I felt that I had survived something. I felt that my spirit was intact.
But there was another side to the story.
I had gone to war with my teacher.
And now, forty-two years later, I can see that war with a clarity that is extraordinarily painful.
Maezumi Roshi was my teacher. I loved him. I respected him. I still have the greatest respect for him.
And we locked horns.
Like two stubborn goats, we kept banging our heads against one another.
I was a young fighter. A green fighter. I had a powerful punch, but I did not yet know how to use it, when to use it, or when not to use it.
He knew what he had in his hands.
He was training me.
There are many ways to use a sword. Many ways to strike. A word can cut as deeply as a stick. And a sword does not always have to be raised.
He was refining me.
I fought back. I challenged him. I pushed him. I was not an easy student.
And yet I learned from him.
I learned more than I could possibly have understood at the time.
Today I can honor him without denying our conflict. I can recognize what he gave me without pretending that either of us was beyond being human.
And I can acknowledge something that has taken me many years to face:
In that struggle, and in the years that followed, I contributed to division within the Sangha.
For that, I am deeply sorry.
My Abuse of Power
During the evening of October 11–12, 2026, I recognized with extreme clarity my abuses of power.
It is absolutely painful.
I must own the fact that I abused my power, both as a young Zen monk in the 1970s and as a teacher from the 1980s until 2011.
Nothing I say changes that fact.
Nothing I say excuses it.
My realization does not excuse it. My years of practice do not excuse it. My understanding of emptiness, prajna, or liberation does not excuse it.
Since January 2011, I have been doing my very best to correct my behavior.
I have continued studying myself, working with my karma, my shadows, and the Precepts—Kai.
I have been learning to live with greater mindfulness and discipline, paying attention to how I conduct myself with body, mind, and spirit.
This is not a claim that I have become perfect.
It is the continuing practice of my life.
My Realization Was Not Wrong
There is something I must make absolutely clear.
My awakening was not wrong.
When body and mind dropped off, what I realized was complete. Absolutely complete.
And it was incomplete.
Not because the realization was false, but because there was more to embody, more to manifest, more to live. There was the other side still to be grown into, matured with life-time.
From the perspective of prajna, nothing is excluded.
When the Buddha raises a finger, that is prajna.
When somebody takes a s**t, that too is prajna.
Everything is prajna.
There is no fixed right and wrong in that realization.
But what is appropriate in one moment may not be appropriate in the next.
Time changes. Circumstances change. People change, positions change. Our understanding changes.
What is appropriate depends upon time, place, position, and degree.
That is not an excuse for my behavior.
It is part of the teaching that I have spent my life discovering and demonstrating.
We cannot freeze wisdom into an idea and then apply that idea mechanically to every situation.
Wisdom must be alive, as living Zen.
Impeccability
Over these past years, and especially during this past year and a half, my understanding of impeccability has continued to deepen.
The Precepts are not merely commandments imposed upon us from outside.
Kai is our true life.
When we receive refuge in the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, we are not giving our lives away to something foreign to us.
We are giving our lives to our truest nature.
And what do we receive?
Our own authentic life.
At first, the Precepts may be like crutches supporting a broken leg.
We need guidance. We need mindfulness. We need discipline.
But as our practice matures, something changes.
We do not merely refrain from harming others because a rule tells us not to.
We simply do not want to harm.
We do not want to speak ill of others. We do not want to elevate ourselves by putting others down. We do not want to take what is not given.
It comes from a very deep place.
And yet we are human.
We miss the mark.
Again and again.
Even when we sit perfectly still, we may be causing suffering somewhere else. Our choices affect our families, our students, our communities, and people we may never meet.
That is why mindfulness matters.
That is why discipline matters.
That is why I continue to practice.
Impeccability is not an image of myself as a flawless Zen Master. It is the living practice of being as fully awake, honest, and appropriate as I can in each situation.
And when I fail, I must be willing to recognize it, acknowledge the consequences, and respond.
The Living Genjō Kōan
My teacher asked me to write the record of my life.
I am doing that now.
My life is my koan.
Not a koan separate from everyday existence. Not something I solved in 1971 and then put away.
My everyday life is the koan.
The awakening in the Mojave Desert.
My years with Maezumi Roshi.
My Dharma transmission.
My departure from the Zen Center of Los Angeles.
The communities I helped create.
The divisions I helped create.
The people I taught.
The people I hurt.
The consequences of my conduct.
The years since 2011.
And this very moment, sitting here, drinking my coffee, wanting to call my wife.
All of it.
This is my Genjō Kōan.
And everyone has their own living koan.
I understand my life as a manifestation of Dōgen Zenji’s teaching—not because I am beyond error, but because nothing in this life stands outside the practice.
I want the record to show the whole process.
The awakening and the blindness.
The wisdom and the immaturity.
The liberation and the consequences.
The teacher and the student.
The sword and the hand that holds it.
The apology and the continuing life.
For the Dharma
I know that some people will never agree with my understanding.
That is not why I am writing.
I am not asking anyone to change their opinion of me.
I am not asking anyone to forget what happened.
I am not asking for my place back.
I am leaving this record for posterity, for those who come after us, and for the Dharma.
I want people to see what a life of practice can actually contain.
I want them to understand that realization does not turn a human being into an idealized image of perfection.
And I want them to understand that acknowledging harm does not require denying the truth of awakening.
I have spent fifty-five years living this practice.
I am still living it.
I am still learning.
I am still discovering what it means to embody the Precepts, to manifest prajna, and to meet each moment appropriately.
And I am deeply sorry for the harm I have caused and the divisions I have helped create.
I cannot undo the past.
But I can tell the truth about it as clearly as I am able.
That is what I am attempting here.
Not the final word.
Not the conclusion of the koan.
The living record.
My life is my koan.
And the koan is still unfolding.
Genpo Roshi
October 2026