07/15/2026
This post is the third of four of our Oconto Falls Main Street Historical buildings and businesses. This one will highlight the west side of Main Street from Central Avenue to Caldwell Avenue. As always please help us with your information, pictures, and comments. Please refer to the Main Street map with the building numbering as before.
42 Presently unknown occupants and commonly referred to as the Shellman Building. The original building was built in 1882 as the Company Store. The 1904 map does show a general store. It burned in 1934 and was rebuilt to present form. Former businesses. Jess McCaully Butcher Shop, Falls Hardware from 1937 (Owner A.J. Peterson),Lehner&Lehner others Behling, Larry Jeske, Vance Wangnerlawyers), Doctor Fred Titel (dentist), Shellman Publishing, R.E.A. Store.
43 Presently unknown occupants but still has the Falls Flying Dragons Sign. Built 19teens by Otto Wottner. Not shown on 1919 map? Had bowling alley in basement, on main level Grant Peterson Variety Store. Then Ben Franklin. Then owned by Gresti Family which ran a fitness center till 2018.
Should be about 100 years old.
44/45 Presently Oconto Falls Insurance Center in front owned by the Stazak family. Jim M. states this building was built prior to the 1871 Peshtigo Fire as The Hotel Schrubbe which he says it survived. It was Oconto Falls first hotel and We have a great early picture of it! It had it's own livery that was located where Una's is now. Later the hotel became The Tourtilott Hotel. Much later Emil Spiegel built the front as it is presently which hides most of the original Hotel. Businesses included Wahl Sporting Goods, Thorp Finance, Wisconsin Finance, grocery store, and meat market. There might be some rental apartments in back. Spiegel ran a grocery and meat market. In 1954 Jerold Witt purchased the grocery and meat business and moved it in 1960 to Una's present location. Martin Drug was there for awhile. From the side parking lot you can check out what should be the oldest building in Oconto Falls. It could be about 155+ years old and still have original structure under the vinyl siding.
46 Presently Una's Unique Resale Mall. In the 1920's William Kadlec and Wesley Christensen built a building on this site for their trucking company that hauled goods for the local paper mill. Later a Mr.
Thomson remodeled the building into a Chevrolet dealership. He was killed in 1952. GM had a policy of no female owned dealership so the dealership was terminated. Mrs. Thomson sold the building to Allen Tisch and Merdon Drews and in 1953 operated Tisch& Drews Trucking. They moved and as stated earlier Jerold Witt remolded the building into a Piggly Wiggly Grocery Store. Later that moved to Highland Drive. Later Car Quest was there. Later Product Motor. While this building was Thompson Cheverolet a photo shows a single story building to the north. It's also shown in the Piggly Wiggly colored photo. A Business sign on it is visible but not legible. Best guess is that the small building was added into the larger. Dale Seeling thought it was a liquor store at one time. The 1919 map shown it as a meat market.
47 Presently maybe vacant. Shown on the 1904 map. In 1920 it was Riemers Resturant and bakery.
Other businesses were Henry Lerquin Jewelry, Effenberger Jewelry, McCauley Butcher Shop, forgotten businesses, cash store, and Red Owl which closed in 1990( George Anderson Owner later Bill Presl).
Should be an original building. 48/49 Presently Beachside Frozen Custard & Grill. One of the newest businesses! Shown on 1904 map. Unsure of businesses before WW2. AfterWW2 was Bahcalls Mercantile and Clothing managed by Bud Anderson, other managers, and lastly Lil McDougal. Then Martin Drug. Then Mag's Decor.
The colored picture of Main Street from the 1960's, which was a post card, may show the Red Owl logo on this building??? Should be an original building.
50 Presently is an apartment building. Referred to as The Flatley Building for William and Theresa Flatley. Shown on 1904 map. The 1919 map shows motion picture theatre and furniture store/telephone exchange which were the Flatley's. The Flatley's lived in the upper level. Later they added a funeral parlor. John Crooks with Sadie Flatley Becker managed the funeral parlor. Later it's believed Greg Flatley managed the furniture store. Later Albert Soulek managed the furniture and funeral businesses and bought the businesses in 1956. He moved the funeral business to Central and Franklin and it's now Jones Funeral Home. Later Albert sold the furniture store to Kent Soulek. Kent died in 1967 and Dave and Pat Trudell ran it till they closed in 1978. Should be an original building.
51 Presently J's Smokeshack BBQ. Shown on 1904 map as two separate buildings. South Saloon and north barber. On 1919 map south pool room and north music. Later it became one building and Andrew Olson put in a bowling alley. Later operated by Harold ( Shortie) Valentine who died in 1948.
Robert (Ridge) Lemonrande purchased/operated till his death in 1979. Later Cliff and Elaine Anderson purchased operated it but later quit the business. Later it was Barb Q Rib and Tavern. Should have some of the original buildings
52 Presently Beam Chemical. Shown on 1904 map. Started by Marion Becker and later sold to Ralph Lemonrande. Later sold to partner Orrie Peterson and still operated by his son Chris Peterson. Was also N.E.W. Finance. Then Wisconsin Finance. Then Thorp Finance. Should be an original building.
53 Presently Vacant? Mostly known as Magnin Hardware building. Shown as a livery on 1904 map.
The 1919 map shows it as store, photographer, and jeweler. Herb King started his shoe store in this building in the 1940's and ran it till 1960. He relocated north of Caldwell. Earnest Magnin started Magnin Hardware here in 1936 by buying out Kilmer Hardware (located where the library is now). His son Orrie (Chub) joined him after WW2. Magnin Hardware expanded taking over Kings Shoe Store half in 1960 and discontinued business in 2009. Should be an original building
54 Presently a rental house. Shown on 1904 map as a boarding house. Meta Wagner owned and rented rooms for many years. She was murdered in 1957 while fishing by the Oconto Falls dam. Should be an original building.