08/20/2026
Some Jewels simply speak for themselves. This is one of them.
BELONGING
DR. DAVID MCCARTY-CAPLAN
When I was twelve, I started introducing myself in Jewish spaces by saying, “Hi! My name is David, and I’m the only Colombian-adopted Jew you will ever meet.”
I truly felt like the only one. Born in Bogotá and adopted at birth into a white Jewish American family, I was raised without any racial mirrors to prepare me for life as a Jew of color.
What I quickly learned was that I was not what people expected Jewishness to look like. In white Jewish settings, I faced uncomfortable microaggressions: “Why are you here?” or “Those are your parents? So you’re not really Jewish.”
All while navigating the profound loss of being disconnected from my lineage and culture of origin. Persistently feeling not Jewish enough. Not white enough. Not Latino enough.
My introduction was a defense mechanism; a preemptive strike to disarm others and make light of how out of place I felt. Worried about everyone else's comfort, I buried my sadness and made a joke of who I was.
As a grown-up, discovering how wrong I was, has made all the difference. There are so many Jews of color and adopted Jews with similar stories of isolation. Finding my people has been transformative, and I have never felt more connected to my Jewish identity.
So today, I work to understand diverse Jewish experiences and build inclusive communities of belonging so future generations of Jews like me never have to feel alone, and be part of a thriving Jewish future.
David McCarty-Caplan is a social work professor and founder of Shades of Belonging, which explores experiences of Jewish adoptees of color. davidmccartycaplan.com
Craig Taubman Julia Caplan
ELUL 8 · DAY 8 of 29 · AUGUST 19, 2026 BELONGINGDR. DAVID MCCARTY-CAPLANWhen I was twelve, I started introducing myself in Jewish spaces by saying, “Hi! My name is David, and I’m the only Colombian-adopted Jew you will ever meet.”I truly felt like the only one. Born in Bogotá and adopted at...