12/10/2025
We are pleased with the outcome of our litigation against the City of Sunnyside and Mayor Dean Broersma. This case was never about politics—it was about protecting a fundamental First Amendment right that belongs to every member of the public. The City’s previous rules of procedure improperly restricted speech at public meetings, and the mayor’s actions in enforcing those rules violated my constitutional rights.
Our lawsuit sought three things: to ensure the City’s policies comply with the U.S. Constitution, to obtain an acknowledgment of the harm caused, and to simply cover attorney costs only. ELLA Adelante did not seek to settle for damages because that was not our aim with the lawsuit. With the City having revised its violating procedure to be in compliance with the US Constitution, and issuing an apology, we believe this resolution affirms the principle that government officials must respect the public’s right to speak.
The message here is simple: constitutional rights are not optional. Public officials are obligated to respect them, and when they don’t, they will be held to account. I hope this case serves as a reminder that transparency, lawful conduct, and respect for public comment are non-negotiable in Sunnyside.
Sunnyside City Council has approved a settlement agreement in Fernandez v. Sunnyside, resolving a dispute stemming from a June 2, 2025, public comment period.