08/01/2025
Restoring the Legacy of Pvt. John Thomas McElfresh, Co. A, 73rd Illinois Infantry – “The Preacher’s Regiment”
Earlier this year, our team successfully cleaned and reset the government-issued headstone of Private John Thomas McElfresh at Oak Ridge Cemetery, Block 11, Lot 167. Although the marker shows signs of typical mineral staining from age and weather, it now stands once again as a proud tribute to a man who served with honor in the American Civil War.
A Carpenter, a Soldier, a Public Servant
Born July 20, 1818 in Montgomery County, Maryland, John McElfresh had built a life as a skilled carpenter before the war. Records show him boarding at the Maxcy House in Springfield and working for wagonmaker J.D. Stratton as early as 1850.
At age 44 (though he claimed to be 42), McElfresh enlisted on August 21, 1862, at Camp Butler in Company A of the 73rd Illinois Volunteer Infantry Regiment, famously nicknamed the “Persimmon Regiment” and “Preacher’s Regiment” due to its high number of ministers among the ranks. Standing 5’5½”, with auburn hair, blue eyes, and a light complexion, McElfresh was mustered into federal service from Mechanicsburg, Illinois.
Less than a year later, he received a disability discharge on September 2, 1863, in Louisville, Kentucky. Despite his brief time in uniform, his service earned him an invalid pension in 1879 (Certificate #218,508) and inclusion in post-war veteran activities, including a regimental reunion in Springfield in 1890.
In 1871, McElfresh was appointed Postmaster of Illiopolis, Illinois, further contributing to his community after the war. Census records trace his life through various towns in Sangamon County, where he continued working as a carpenter and raising a family with his wife, Angeline McDaniel, whom he married on February 11, 1862. Together, they raised several children—Charly, Annie, Willie, and Ella—across residences in Springfield, Illiopolis, and Gardner, Illinois.
Though the Illinois Civil War Muster Rolls list his age as 42 at enlistment, birth records confirm he was 44. Whether he deliberately underreported his age to avoid the age-45 enlistment cutoff remains an open question—a reminder of the personal choices made by older enlistees eager to serve.
Private McElfresh passed away on July 8, 1897, at the age of 78. His obituary noted that his funeral was held at the First Methodist Episcopal Church, officiated by Rev. F.A. Havighorst. He was laid to rest with honor in Oak Ridge Cemetery, where his restored headstone now helps tell his story once more.
Why this matters: Restoring headstones is not only about cleaning marble—it’s about reclaiming the stories etched into them. Every detail, from census listings to pension certificates, helps us piece together the life of a man who served, labored, and lived through one of America’s defining centuries.
Thank you to our team of volunteers and researchers who help us preserve these vital pieces of our shared heritage.