The Church Mouse Thrift Shop of The Sparta United Methodist Church

Directions Website

The Church Mouse Thrift Shop of The Sparta United Methodist Church Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from The Church Mouse Thrift Shop of The Sparta United Methodist Church, Nonprofit Organization, 71 Sparta Avenue, Sparta, NJ.

Mission: to be a resource for those in our community who are in need of assistance, to be good stewards of material possessions through reuse & recycling, to extend our mission worldwide, when & where possible, and to extend God’s love worldwide.

11/02/2026

!!!THRIFT SHOP SALE!!!

"EMERGENCY" PARENTING SUPPLIES!

Nov 4 – Nov 7: Entire Kid’s Department is HALF OFF!

Great news! At 50% off, you can grab a short stack of Dr. Seuss books, a couple of backup kid DVDs, and a board game for less than the price of the very large iced latte you left on the coffee table—the one the dog quietly finished for you 45 minutes ago while you were looking for your missing left shoe.

Here’s what’s 50% OFF:

Plushies & Plastic Toys : Scientifically engineered to be stepped on barefoot in 2:00 AM darkness (or to replace the pieces missing from last year's board games).

Literary "Classics": Re-read Goodnight Moon for the 418th time until the words completely lose all meaning.

Kid DVDs: Essential backup for when the internet dies and your child wanders into the living room, blinks at the sunlight, and remembers they have parents. (True story: our Wi-Fi actually crashed while I was writing this post. My spouse had to drive to Planet Networks for a replacement router just so I could hit publish.)

Wardrobe: Upgrades for children who sprout two inches since our Back-to-School Sale, spill ketchup within 12 seconds of entering a clean vehicle, or treat putting on non-dinosaur pants like a violation of the Geneva Conventions.

Cheap bribes? Early holiday gifts? Pure survival strategy? Whatever your reason, come raid the shelves before another caffeinated parent claims the jackpot!

P.S. Speaking of that espresso-fueled pup… you should probably go let them out to p*e right about now.

Send a message to learn more

10/21/2026

ATTENTION SHOPPERS!

🚨 Early Close Alert! 🚨

We’re closing early (at 1:00 PM) this Saturday! 🕐✨

Make sure to swing by early on Saturday to grab your weekend thrift finds before we lock up. See you soon! 🛍️👇

Send a message to learn more

10/17/2026

SALE! SALE! SALE!

ATTENTION FALL SHOPPERS: MAXIMUM DRAMA IN THE WOMEN’S DEPARTMENT!

Ladies, girls, and teens, basically anyone whose closet is currently crying for help—drop what you are doing. The Church Mouse Thrift Shop has officially pressed the giant red panic button and slashed prices by 50%. Honestly, at this point, we're just daring you to clean us out.

We are talking about a total wardrobe takeover:

Women’s, Girl’s and Teen’s Clothes: Fill your cart so fast your bank account won't even have time to panic.

Women’s Shoes: Because you deserve a pair of cute boots that are actually comfortable for once.

Purses: To carry the snacks, receipts, and emotional baggage you collect on a daily basis.

Scarves: For pretending you live in a romantic indie film.

The Fine Print: Diamonds may be a girl's best friend, but jewelry is strictly sitting this party out (excluded from the sale). Everything else in the Women’s Department (including Girls & Teens) is fair game!

Come claw your way through the racks before someone else steals your thunder (or your size).

Where: Sparta UMC’s Church Mouse Thrift Shop
When: Wed. October 21 – Sat. October 24

May the odds be ever in your fashion favor!

~OBLIGATORY DISCLAIMER: Everything on this page is subject to human error, autocorrect sabotage, and our general state of whimsy. We are not responsible for misprints or misunderstandings, especially since our in-house comedic writer is frequently operating on high hopes and low amounts of sleep. If a post seems too good to be true, it’s probably a typo. Or a miracle. But mostly a typo. Please shop—and read—accordingly. Any resemblance between our descriptions and actual reality is purely coincidental.

Send a message to learn more

SALE! 75% OFF ALL HALLOWEEN COSTUMES AND HALLOWEEN DECOR FROM Wed 10/7 THROUGH Sat 10/10! Note: Does not include fall dé...
10/06/2026

SALE! 75% OFF ALL HALLOWEEN COSTUMES AND HALLOWEEN DECOR FROM Wed 10/7 THROUGH Sat 10/10! Note: Does not include fall décor.

-----

ATTENTION GHOULS, GOBLINS, AND DREAD-FILLED PARENTS!
Welcome to October, a month-long horror film where you spend $60 on a polyester jumpsuit that gets abandoned on the curb before trick-or-treating even ends, and another $80 on a plastic skeleton that judges your un-mowed lawn for three straight weeks.

Save your wallet from an early grave. The Church Mouse Thrift Shop is here to perform an exorcism on ridiculously high retail prices.

From October 7th through October 10th, we are slashing prices by a terrifying 75% ON ALL HALLOWEEN COSTUMES AND HALLOWEEN DECOR!

Yes, 75% off actual, full-fledged, ready-to-wear costumes AND spine-chilling Halloween house gear. We’ve got the racks stocked and the shelves hauntingly stacked, so you don't have to suffer through:

Kids: A costume they swear is their "favorite thing ever" on Tuesday, declare "ruins their life" on Thursday, and demand to wear to bed on Halloween night.

Teens: A disguise for the one single night of the year they voluntarily step out into the sunlight to wander the neighborhood in packs.

Adults: An effortless, full outfit that lets you answer the door without having to explain why your "costume" is just your normal everyday clothes with a pair of plastic ears.

Your Porch: Looking like a sad, un-decorated wasteland while your neighbor turns their front yard into a full-scale, fog-machine-powered haunted mansion. We've got the ghoulish decorations to make your house look spooktacular without terrifying your bank account!

Skip the temporary pop-up stores where a single mask or plastic pumpkin costs the equivalent of a kidney on the black market. Come grab real costumes and wicked decor for pocket change before the best stuff vanishes into the night!

Doors open Wednesday, October 7th. Come get spooky for pennies!

ATTENTION:  HOLY GOURD, THE FALL MERCH HAS ARRIVED!Clear a path, bargain hunters—the shop just transformed into a glorio...
09/01/2026

ATTENTION: HOLY GOURD, THE FALL MERCH HAS ARRIVED!

Clear a path, bargain hunters—the shop just transformed into a glorious vortex of autumn energy, spooky vibes, and questionable decision-making. We've got Halloween, Thanksgiving, and general harvest madness ready for you to hunt through!

We’ve been popping open mystery boxes back here like overly enthusiastic squirrels, and the thrift gods have officially blessed us with... stuff! Lots and lots of fall-adjacent, harvest-flavored, spooky-season stuff.

What Mystery Treasures Await You?

Autumn-esque Odds & Ends: A roulette wheel of cozy treasury, festive items, and autumn stuff you suddenly can’t live without.

Spooky-Season Oddities: Unpredictable Halloween weirdness and ghost-adjacent treasures that are way too silly to actually haunt your house.

Thanksgiving Shenanigans: A free-for-all of festive home accents that will make your dining room look like fall exploded in it.

Cozy Swag & Warm Layers: Soft things! Plaid things! Wearable threads of unknown origins! Whatever it takes to keep you warm when the temperature drops.

Because it’s thrift, once these random acts of fall decor are gone, they are gone. We cannot promise what’s in the shop until you come take a p*ek for yourself!

Come raid the racks, embrace the seasonal chaos, and snag some weird harvest magic before your neighbor buys it all out of pure impulse. See you soon!

Comment below if you are excited for fall shopping at The Church Mouse Thrift Shop of The Sparta United Methodist Church!

08/31/2026

On Saturday the thrift shop closed to the public to host its biannual Nonprofit Day. During this event, invited families from local partner organizations shop the entire store—clothing, home goods, essentials, etc—completely for FREE. Approximately 145 people came to shop!

Invited organizations included Project Self-Sufficiency, Samaritan Inn, Norwescap, Newton Free Clinic, Benny's Bodega, Feed The Body Feed The Soul, Ginnie's House, Market Street Mission, Family Promise, and Devereux Group Home.

Following the event, volunteers began a complete store transformation: clearing out remaining inventory for donation or recycling, deep cleaning the facility, and restocking the floor with fresh merchandise.

08/16/2026

ATTENTION ACCIDENTAL COLLECTORS, PEOPLE WHOSE CAR TRUNKS ARE ALREADY FULL, AND FOLKS WHO CANNOT BE LEFT UNSUPERVISED WHILE THRIFTING!

Clear your car trunk, stretch your browsing arms, and mentally prepare your living space for items you did not know existed five minutes ago: EVERYTHING in the entire shop is 50% OFF from August 19th through August 28th!

That’s right—50% off everything. The kind of aggressive, jaw-dropping discount where you calculate the price in your head, realize you're paying less than the cost of two minutes of vacuuming time at a car wash, and immediately look around to see if security is going to tackle you. You’re not stealing, but spiritually? You’re walking out with grand larceny energy.

Will you find wardrobe upgrades (think gloriously unnecessary hats, retro denim, and outfits that say "I have my life together."), surprisingly bougie kitchenware, and suspiciously cryptic books? 97.99% chance yes.

You may or may not also happen to stumble upon:

A yard gnome having a full existential crisis.

An instructional VHS tape from 1994 titled Intermediate Clog Dancing for Solitary Adults.

A framed cross-stitch that reads, "I know what you did!”, in perfect pastel letters, but $2 is $2.

A mysterious ornate key that unlocks a door no currently living person has ever opened.

A retro novelty cookie jar that quacks aggressively every time you open it. (The ultimate diet plan.)

The thrill of the hunt is entirely real, but the prices are HALF OFF.

Whatever bizarre, brilliant, or utterly unexplainable treasure is meant to end up on your coffee table—or crammed into your attic—it’s waiting for you starting August 19th!

Set your alarms, tag a friend who won't ask questions, and come ready to dig!

08/06/2026

Quick heads-up, wonderful thrifters! 📦❤️

On Saturday August 29th, we are CLOSED for a private event, so no donations can be accepted on that day.

As much as we love a good surprise drop-off, please keep those lovely boxes tucked safely at home until we open again on that Wednesday. Thank you for being such an amazing community and holding onto those gems for us. We appreciate you!

08/02/2026

SALE! SALE! SALE!

Parents, caretakers, and exhausted guardians of the universe: hear ye, hear ye!

The heralds are sounding, the birds are singing a slightly sweeter tune, and the internal soundtrack of your life is suddenly blasting Andy Williams. That’s right. It is officially The Most Wonderful Time of the Year.

No, not the one with the snow and the jolly man in the red suit. We are talking about the glorious season where the sweet, sweet sound of school bells prepares to replace the repetitive, agonizing summer refrain of “I’m bored”, “There’s nothing to eat.”, and "Timmy hit me first!"

To celebrate your upcoming freedom—er, your children’s educational enrichment—The Church Mouse Thrift Shop is throwing the ultimate celebration.

From August 5th through August 8th, we are slashing prices by 50% OFF for our massive ‘Back to School’ Sale!

We have racks upon racks of incredible kids and teens clothing ready for the picking. Because let’s face it:

Your child grew four inches overnight, and their current pants look like capris.

Your teenager refuses to wear anything that doesn't meet their hyper-specific, ever-changing style aesthetic (which currently mirrors a mix of 90s grunge and "I got dressed in the dark").

You know deep in your soul that whatever you buy will inevitably be covered in grass stains, mystery cafeteria sauce, or acrylic paint by week two anyway. Why pay full price for future floor-rags?

Whether you need to outfit a pint-sized comedian who thinks pants should be optional at home and in assorted retail establishments or a teenager who communicates strictly in grunts and TikTok trends, we’ve got you covered for half the price.

Skip the chaotic malls, save your sanity, and keep your hard-earned cash for the things that really matter—like the extra-large iced coffees required to survive until the first day of school.

Doors open at the Church Mouse on Wednesday, August 5th. Come join the celebration. It truly is the most wonderful time of the year! 🎒✏️✨

Address

71 Sparta Avenue
Sparta, NJ
07871

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10am - 2pm
Thursday 1pm - 4pm
Friday 1pm - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Church Mouse Thrift Shop of The Sparta United Methodist Church posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share