06/17/2026
Am I the a**hole for following a stranger through a grocery store for twenty minutes because she looked like my de*d daughter?
I (45M) lost my daughter Becca eight years ago. She was nineteen. Car accident, two weeks into her first semester of college. I have a son, Derek (22), a wife, Pam (49), and what I thought was a mostly functional life. I go to work, I mow the lawn, I do the grocery run on Sunday mornings because it gives Pam a break and it gives me something to do with my hands.
Last Sunday I was at the Kroger on Whitfield, standing in the cereal aisle, when I saw her.
Not her. I know that. I'm not crazy.
But this girl - maybe twenty, dark hair pulled up the same way Becca always wore it, same slope to her shoulders, same way of tilting her head when she read the label on something - my chest just stopped working.
I told myself I was going to grab my box of granola and leave. I didn't.
I followed her. Produce. Dairy. The frozen section. I kept about half an aisle back and I didn't say anything, I just - I needed to see her face from the front. That's what I told myself. Just once, from the front, and then I'd go.
When she finally turned around near the bread, she didn't look like Becca at all. Different nose, different eyes. I don't know what I was even seeing before.
She caught me looking. I must have had some expression on my face because she pulled out her phone immediately and took a step back.
I said, "I'm sorry, you just reminded me of someone."
She said, "You've been following me."
I said, "I know. I'm sorry. My daughter - she passed away and you - "
She said, "I don't care," and she walked away fast toward the front of the store.
I stood there by the bread for a while. Then I finished shopping. When I got home, Pam asked if I was okay and I told her what happened, the whole thing, and she just looked at me and said, "Terry. That poor girl."
She wasn't wrong. I know she wasn't wrong.
But then Derek called that night, and Pam told him, and Derek said I needed to "get help" and that this "wasn't the first time" something like this had happened, and I didn't know what he meant by that, so I asked Pam.
The way she looked at me when I asked.
"Terry," she said. "You really don't remember the woman at the gas station? Or the girl at Derek's graduation?"
My friends and family are split - Derek thinks I need to see someone, Pam's more careful about what she says but I can see it in her face. Maybe they're right that I went too far in the store. But what Derek said, about it not being the first time - I don't have any memory of those other moments.
None.
And when I told Pam that, she sat down at the kitchen table and said, "Okay. Then there's something I need to show you."
She went upstairs. She came back down with a folder.
👇