07/11/2020
A Great Opportunity
First I hope you all are well and dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic and all the unrest in the country as best as you can and that you had a good Independence Day holiday. Whatever our problems are, we are still fortunate to live in this country. These are difficult times for sure, that are tough on everyone. Hikes in the Preserve can really help adjust to whatever issues we have to face so we are very fortunate to have such an amenity right in our city.
While there is a lot to worry about, we have a unique opportunity this year to change the makeup of the Scottsdale city council that we not only shouldn’t ignore but embrace doing that will not only help our efforts to protect the Preserve but make sure growth is compatible with our city and the quality of life we enjoy here. Opportunities like this don’t come often so we have to take advantage of them when they do.
In 2018, we got 2 people involved with Proposition 420 elected and they have done a wonderful job. This year, we are fortunate to have 2 more people, who were both instrumental in giving us a vote on development in the Preserve through the Proposition 420 charter change, running for city council seats, Betty Janik and Tom Durham. Like Kathy Littlefield and Solange Whitehead, they are smart, articulate, and will make good decisions when it comes to growth, managing fiscal responsibility, and preserving our quality of life, making their decisions based on the facts, not what some donor to their campaign wants. They will truly represent us citizens and combined with Kathy and Solange will give us a majority on the council. With a majority of 4 we can better protect the Preserve and control growth so it complements our quality of life rather than degrading it.
The COVID-19 crisis and the riots and looting in our own downtown exposed a severe lack leadership in Scottsdale. Leadership comes from the top, mayor and council majority, not from city staff. Both the mayor, and council majority have been absent when it counts the most. The bars should have been closed in the beginning and remained closed until the virus is under control and the city should have prepared for the riots, that were hitting cities all over the nation way before they came to Scottsdale. Strategies for handing them should have been established before they happened. The mayor with council majority of Korte, Klapp, and Milhaven wouldn’t clamp down on the bars or work with our police and fire departments to prepare for riots because they are supported by the bar owners through contributions to campaign funds. We need a real leader to guide us through these difficult times and also through the financial impact of them on the city, which will be considerable.
By the way, the good news on the riots is that the Scottsdale police department is continuing to follow up on leads and arrest those responsible for property destruction and looting. More arrests are being made every day. Despite lack of mayor/council leadership, they are doing everything they can to send a strong message that you won’t get away with those actions in Scottsdale.
Leadership starts with the mayor and there are 5 candidates for mayor. All have been council members in the past, so we know their voting record AND who contributes to their campaign, both now and in the past. The only candidate who hasn’t taken money from these special interests is Bob Littlefield. He is also the only candidate with a proven voting record of supporting citizens vs. developers, land owners, and their attorneys. He is a Vet who will take charge when needed, something we haven’t seen in the past 12 years. Some people say they don’t want two Littlefields on the council but for me I would have 7 of them on the council if all of them consistently supported citizens and responsible growth, and backed that up with their votes and actions, as Bob and Kathy have done. Korte and Klapp have continuously voted to increase height and density and have not listened to citizens. Korte also spent a lot of time and money trying to deny us a vote on development in the Preserve, again showing her distain for citizen’s opinions. Klapp was solidly behind the DDC, alias Desert Edge, until it became clear we were going to get our charter question to the voters, and then she was suddenly in favor of 420. While we appreciate that, if she were on our side from the beginning we wouldn’t have needed to go through the extensive effort to change the charter. Borowsky, and her family, are developers, currently trying to stuff a high density development in a rural area near Sedona and her voting record while on council was poor, supporting both development and the bars. Ortega isn’t a bad person, but his voting record leaves a lot to be desired plus he was an opponent of the Preserve. So the choice for mayor should be pretty clear.
Who are the best council candidates to lead us through this uncertain future? Who will represent citizens instead of those who want to profit off Scottsdale’s desirability? As with mayoral candidates, all you have to do is follow the money. If you look at who contributes to their campaign fund, it is pretty easy to see who to not vote for as the majority of them are taking donations from people and companies who do business with the city, which may be legal but certainly not ethical. It means they are bound to vote for whatever projects their donors or organizations bring before the council regardless of their impact on the city and its citizens. So you know how they will vote and who they will represent and it won’t be you.
Betty Janik and Tom Durham are the only candidates completely free of special interest donations. All theirs came from average citizens just like us. Guy Phillips is close and in the process of returning any donations that may even appear to be unethical and so far Michael Auerbach is also free of special interest donations. All the others have either taken donations from people who do business with the city or have connections with organizations that want to develop the city like the Scottsdale Area Chamber of Commerce, the Scottsdale Area Association of Relators (SAAR), and the Scottsdale Coalition of Today and Tomorrow (SCOTT). All of these groups are very political and want to develop Scottsdale into another version of Phoenix or LA by getting their people on the city council. This will become even more apparent when the second quarter financial reports come out on July 16th. Look at donations and their connections to people, companies and organizations to see who is backing these candidates and therefore who they will represent if they get on the council.
If you want to learn more about the candidates, a great source of information is the Coalition of Greater Scottsdale (COGS) web site where they have posted questionnaires from all but the 2 candidates that didn’t return one (Crawford and Auerbach) and also the first quarter financial reports. If you look through this material it becomes pretty clear who to vote for. Go to: http://cogsaz.net/ and select “2020 Council and Mayoral Candidates Info”.
We have also put a candidate information summary on the Protect Our Preserve website at:http://protectourpreserve.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Candidate_List_C.pdf
It contains a brief summary of each candidate, their connections, voting history, and 1st quarter financial statement plus how they answered key questions in the COGS survey. You might find it helpful. The intent is to just present the facts.
We are going through a very difficult time with the virus and general unrest in the country, but we can make a big difference locally, and therefore how these things impact us in the future, by putting the right people on the city council. This year we have a chance to change the makeup of the council to one that really will represent citizens, will look at responsible growth, retain our quality of life, and drive the city toward financial sustainability. If we get 5 council members who are resident friendly, we can also create a real General Plan to guide future development and give us some predictability of what Scottsdale will be in the future. Two years ago we made a huge difference by passing Proposition 420 and electing two citizen friendly candidates, all by wide margins. We can build on that by electing at least 3 more good candidates this year, all we need are votes for the right people. As before, if we stick together we can make a big difference.
Please pass this along to anyone you know who is a Scottsdale voter, every vote counts.
Thanks and stay well.
Howard
Alert
Voters who are not registered as a Democrat or Republican WILL NOT automatically get a ballot for the Primary election even if are on the Permanent Early Voting List. They are sent a card that gives them the option of requesting a political party ballot of their choice or a Scottsdale-only ballot. These voters must notify Maricopa County Elections (602-506-1511) of their selection to receive a mail-in ballot for the August 4, 2020 Primary Election. Ballot selections also may be made online at:
https://recorder.maricopa.gov/earlyvotingballot/earlyvotingballotrequest.aspx.
This must be done by July 24th to get a ballot and vote by July 29th (last day to mail a ballot back).