10/01/2024
Teacher Retention in rural Alaska, the untold story. The reality of what our education system is causing. The harm to these very poor village communities who have been sold down the river of hopelessness and poverty.
By, David Allen Mitchell
SPECIAL NOTE: The first thing I want to write is that the new idea of hiring Philipino teachers for “emergency contracts” is not their fault. There are many very good teachers who come here to better their lives and make money beyond their capabilities and dreams in the Philipines. The Philipines is a very poor country where their own education system is facing serious financial problems of even have books in classrooms and resources for underpaid teachers.
These “emergency hire” teachers are being used as a tool to protect this current Alaskan system of failure being found out. These Philipinos cannot be blamed for helping to protect this opportunity for their own wealth that the school districts are knowingly providing as a way to mislead the public in why there is a current teacher shortage or problem retaining teachers.
I truly wish these wonderful Philipino teachers could use their skills in helping reform the system not by being a pawn to help protect it.
IT IS AN EMERGENCY, KNOW THE FACTS! Alaska Native villages please read and pass along. TAKE THE TIME to read this report and letter.
What is happening throughout Rural schools in Alaska should be questioned and answers need to be demanded. Throughout rural schools the little known fact that the teacher shortage or problem associated with retaining teachers throughout Alaska is the DIRECT result of the school districts administrative propaganda directed toward how they have continued to protect the system of failure.
The school districts have mislead the public for so long there may not be a chance to correct what they have caused. One thing though, we have the chance to now expose the secrets that have been hidden for so long. Open your eyes and ears. Be willing and want to see and hear the truth.
There are 1000’s of teachers who were unfairly either non retained or removed or “not recommended for rehire ” thus forced to resign. This has taken an huge affect and toll on teachers retention. Very few take the risk to remain in the system with their careers being threatened. This is a hidden fact that once again is used to help the top administrators in the state of Alaska to protect their own agenda. It is designed to prevent any teacher or educator who questions the system or rocks their boat.
Scratch the surface on this new wave of teachers coming into your schools. They are getting emergency contracts to teach here. Their loyalty is being bought and used to run the schools while hurting each community. I ask every parent to go to the schools.
Count how many teachers are now from the Philipines. Some schools have almost every teacher. These schools are the center of each community. Look at what they profess to be bringing as jobs and ways to promote each local community. Don’t look at how they have crossed t’s or dotted i’s. Look at what your children are learning and if there are changes in the school to help with their futures and getting their communities out of poverty and hopelessness!
ASK WHY MANY OF THE SUPPORT JOBS are now going to the relatives of these Philippine teachers? Many of the answers are going to be avoided or someone will be told they “could not find qualified people to fill them”? They use excuses for why they have to hire teachers relatives as support staff. What are they suggesting then? The district administrators now are creating another myth that needs to be asked about. They want the locals to not ask questions and go along with the easy answers of, “we are protecting the students”. I call BS!
Once these teachers come into the schools there will be a 5 year time period (they get 4 or 5 year emergency work visas in the US) where no new ideas or teachers will be allowed to apply or be hired for each position filled. They retained these foreign teachers for 5 years, then claim they only hire them on emergency basis. But they don’t tell the public those positions will be locked and closed for 5 years not allowing new teachers from the U.S. to even be aware of previous openings. They keep qualified teachers away from even having the ability to apply. There are no job openings being listed from those “emergency” teachers hired the year prior.
This new idea of hiring these foreign teachers from impoverished countries needs to be looked at and questioned. This idea once again misleads the public and misrepresents the facts. They have not solved this problem of retention and teachers being hired that want to come and be part of the communities. The schools administration and this system have covered up what they have caused! Hiring teachers from a third world nation is letting down our whole process. It only makes sense to the administrators protecting their system of failure.
Do the school districts want the locals now to believe there are not any local people who are qualified and who want jobs or apply for jobs at the schools? These are support jobs such as teachers aids, janitors, maintenance, or kitchen workers which every community member can be easily qualified for are now going to the relatives of these “emergency teachers”. So now there is also a shortage of support staff qualified applicants in schools therefore those jobs need to be filled with these teachers relatives? COME ON! REALLY?
Get into the community and find out how many need jobs and work just to feed their families? Maybe ask more questions to why some locals have been fired, let go, or not being allowed to apply? Do not allow the easy answers of they were protecting the students. Be smarter, and ask specifics and allow those who have been let go to represent themselves by giving their side and the facts. What you will find is that maybe the employee made a mistake but it did not warrant the punishment. We all make mistakes but don’t allow these mistakes to be used in bad faith against your communities. It makes more sense to learn and allow these people and system to grow. The employees should not have lost their ability to feed their family and pay their bills.
FIND OUT THE DETAILS of why these locals were fired or not allowed to apply in the schools? In most cases no laws have been broken only accusations preventing them and scaring them out of employment. The schools won’t answer claiming it is privileged and personnel decisions cannot be talked about. I call BS again. Find out and ask the support staff what really is going on. Some locals make one mistake and the districts use that to prevent them from ever being hired again. With nobody to represent this local group of employees they become “at will” being let go easily. These same people slip back into being unemployed into hopelessness and poverty they try so hard to get out of.
The only time there have been lawsuits is when the background checks from people hired as support staff for the schools were from teachers families. Let the local boards take each individual incident from why locals are being let go and let them decide. Do not allow the administrators to use that to move another “emergency contract teachers” relative in to take a very good job from locals. In a town of of over 1000 people they want us to believe that at least 4 full time positions and daily subs cannot be found in a place that unemployment is off the charts? I call BS! There simply are very few jobs in these villages.
The school administrators have been so successful on running off the good teachers in the past who rock their boat that they are now using the same technique in schools for support staff hiring. They know these foreign relatives of these teachers will show up for work and NEVER questions anyone. The school districts are a huge part of the causes for such extreme poverty and hopelessness in these villages but never accept responsibility.
AND maybe these relatives of emergency teachers do a better job? Of course they do exactly what they are told without having to deal with the realities of life in the village. They live in “palaces on the hill” that the district provides for them to live a good life without the challenges each native faces on a daily basis. AND because these teachers and their relatives are making a small fortune compared to what they would be paid in their home country they are perfect for these districts to continue misleading the public and harming these villages.
Our current school system is contributing directly to the poverty and hopelessness instead of helping to be a solution. SO WHAT if they are doing a better job! The Schools need to train and find ways to fill those positions until they find the right people from the COMMUNITY! We can’t blame the teachers relative but should hold the school administration accountable for their actions. This should not be negotiable.
If this school system has already put into motion helping get “emergency visas or emergency work permits for support staff” then ask yourself what was the intentions when districts lobbied for that? Was it to help the community and the schools? The obvious answer is NO! This doesn’t do anything but protect their system of failure while creating even MORE POVERTY and hopelessness for these native communities. But success for their own pocket books.
Yes, they hire one or two or three locals and they put them on a pedestal to protect the image of local hire. That is propaganda directed at your intelligence and your local ability to help run these schools.
The first question is who has promoted and pushed through getting legal work permits for these support staff jobs going to the relatives of these teachers? Are they working here legally? Then ask how many local community members now have been forced out from working for one reason or another stating they are concerned with student safety? The numbers are going to be alarming. Are background checks done on these relatives from their home country?
In the past the districts have become experts at misrepresenting the facts and misleading the public. So don’t accept the first easy answer provided. Get the actual figures from the accountants paying the staff. Get all the public records and facts. Don’t believe the spin districts tend to use to keep their actions hidden. These districts control what they say to the media and nobody ever challenges them… NEA and school boards should! These districts continue to misrepresent facts and hide their direct involvement with the poverty they help create.
***THE LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS are filled with old board members who have sat around allowing things to get to this point, while being unwilling to get in there and demand answers. Get fresh new minds in their to help represent the community and young people! Change your communities with new ideas not old ideas that are recycled and never worked in the first place. Get YOUNG PEOPLE voted in if the old people don’t want to learn and grow! The answer is to let young people come in and help change their futures!
Many of the Principals who ran good teachers and these individuals off, are no longer employed in that school nor really care about what is happening. Lots of times they simply get transferred to another school in the district to continue to promote and protect the system of failure. I taught for over 15 years in these rural areas. Each community is SUFFERING from the decisions of the past Principals and administrators decisions that will forever affect the young people and the schools. Ask yourself in villages around the state if the local school boards are demanding change?
For those in Savoonga there is a VERY GOOD example. Ask how shutting down Pizza Hutski (the student restaurant which had over 60 students involved) has affected the young people and community? Now we live with that decision, while another young man like BEN dies with no hope for his future when he commits su***de. And yes I say this knowing the truth. Anytime I wanted answers I was targeted and ran off. I was non retained in a high School and denied an opportunity to resign. Now that high school has 100% foreign teachers filling the positions. The reason given was that I was not doing what the school required and I was given a “plan of improvement”. Which was found to be unjust but not removed.
With this plan of improvement they can justify non retaining a teacher or firing them for next year eligibility. This has been strategically placed in contracts with making non tenured teachers in their first 3 years “at will” employees with NEA not willing to protect these teachers jobs.
***THE ALASKA NEA TEACHERS UNION have backed and supported the non retentions by not representing any non tenured teacher for many years within the negotiated contracts. They have sat on the same side of the table protecting this system of failure. Maybe it is time they start helping ALL teachers not just those tenured teachers who have become part of the system too? Hopefully NEA is looking at the damage they have sat by and allowed. It is time they start trying to correct what they helped cause. Which has created this current system we see before us. TEACHERS NEED NEA and TEACHERS UNIONS TO GET OFF THE SIDELINES AND START HELPING TEACHERS!
Savoonga is a community of over 1000 people. The school districts want these communities to believe they cannot find people to employ in the support jobs in the school? Those in Savoonga, go in and ask why there are at least 4 full time positions of support staff and many substitute jobs now being filled by these relatives and not locals? Don’t believe they can’t find people to fill those positions. That should NEVER be the case.
Schools should be required to fill them with locals without exception. It is their job to find qualified people to fill them and train them. If they don’t then it is their fault not the communities. This is not an isolated problem in Savoonga! Many schools now have the same issue and nobody is willing to get the answers. Community members are scared of being retaliated on by the districts. Why are people not asking? The poverty is caused by these decisions. Get active and play a role in positive change.
In my 15 years I taught/coached in Savoonga, Kalskag, Sand Point, Wainwright, and Buckland Alaska. Everything I am writing and saying is from first hand experiences in the trenches of some of the most beautiful but challenging places in the world. In EVERY district I ever taught at I challenged and fought to help create the much needed change without any huge results. It is time to speak out. I put my career on the line each and every village I taught at. However, my job as a teacher and coach stands on its own!
I am proud of the work and job I have done teaching and coaching throughout the state. It speaks for itself. Ask those young people and their parents who know me. The district makes it a practice to come after teachers who are willing to challenge this system. I am ready for that challenge. My resume stands on its own.
WHAT ARE THE SCHOOLS NOW DOING? Have they secretly and privately supported bringing in Philipino family members and promising them positions in your schools? If not then how do these family members have working visas when they arrive here? Are they working here legally? The school districts are using this group of foreign employees to solve their problems and cover up their past bad faith at the communities expense.
In Savoonga there are at least 4 full time support staff from the Philipines now working in that school. I am confident that EVERY RURAL school in Alaska they are having the same issues. Ask questions. Find some answers. Here is the reality of these family members taking the jobs of the support staff in the schools. I personally know it is not true that they cannot find qualified people to fill the positions. They have been creative in how they fire some locals where they can justify having an open position. I also want to know how do these family members have the right to be employed in rural Alaska and how did they get their work permit?
Let’s take a support staff who makes around $40,000.00 - $70,000.00 per year. Check the pay scales. Lets say there are now at least 4 full time employed staff which have support jobs from the Philipines. That is money (between $160,000.00 - $280,000.00 a year) that has been taken from an already impoverished village and given to people where in their home country they would make less than $500.00 per month for the same equivalent job. That is per month. And that is a fact.
They come and take the jobs and money from these very remote areas. 4 jobs (maybe more) x $50,000.00 (lets meet in the middle) a year. That is $200,000.00 a year not going to community members that are living in some of the worse poverty in the world. This does NOT include the substitute daily money that is being hidden from the public. Then these teachers bring their families to make this huge money from where they come from making them very very wealthy. Beyond their dreams. Ask how did this happen? Then ask who they are loyal to and who will they support with not reforming our current system and looking for ways to improve this educational system of failure?
***NOW THE DISTRICTS ARE ASKING TO EXTEND THE EMERGENCY VISAS. They want to extend them past 5 years. Whose problem are they solving? Is it the communities in improving the education system or is it the school districts making sure they protect this system of failure and prevent any changes? They are hiding the reality of what they have helped cause and be part of. These districts have become experts at recycling old ideas that never worked in the first place while claiming they are making great progress. I call BS again! Don’t allow them to mislead these communities down the same old road.
This newest trend of schools now almost being exclusively foreign Philipino staff has happened because the school districts continue to misrepresent the truth and mislead the public in how they are running these schools throughout Alaska. Don’t take my word for it. Let’s take that $200,000.00 and multiply it by the years they come because our schools districts are bringing them in here as an emergency to fill the void of all the teachers prior who were ran off and non retained. Not only that their family members are also getting rich by taking the jobs of the very needy locals.
In 5 years they can come work under emergency contracts, it is simple math. They will have potentially taken over 1 MILLION dollars , that’s right, $1,000,000.00 from each local economy. The districts are now finding other ways to keep these teachers here by creating different visas such as hiring under other emergency contracts and placing them into administration. With no opposition of NEA or anyone challenging these actions it will become laws or procedures that are going to be very hard to change. Get involved! Get the local school boards to get involved not sit on the sidelines with NEA.
DO THE MATH AND ASK QUESTIONS. How is this helping the young people? And how is this helping the future of these communities? They have came up with a system that they are depending on nobody asking or caring. I heard a principal tell me personally that came from Oklahoma that these people are just lazy drunks who cannot come to work. I will testify and swear to this under oath.
WHY DOES THIS MATTER TO ME? The answer is simple. Because I am tired of burying young people in these areas who have no hope for their futures and take their own young lives. Most of these young people endure extreme poverty with no hope for the future our schools are NOT preparing them for.
The answer is not to turn over your schools and communities to districts. These districts have created a system that acts in bad faith and is more concerned with protecting this system of failure than protecting the integrity of how they operate and run these schools.
Ask your school boards to not sit on the sidelines while being promised trips and paid money so they can let the Superintendent run these school. I have personally heard admistrators tell each other they put the local school board members on the board who will not question or cause any issues with how they run the school. I will testify to this under oath.
We cannot continue to allow this system of failure to hurt our young people and these communities. If we do not demand answers and become more proactive these districts are now asking to extend these emergency teachers contracts.
I beg everyone to please go to your schools and start asking for answers.
Go to the local media, go to the newspapers! Ask who’s job is to give a fair and equal story to this problem of not finding local or United States teachers and this teacher shortage? Almost without exception our media has allowed these districts and educators to misrepresent and hide the truth behind why there is a shortage of teachers and their ability to retain teachers.
***THE DISTRICTS CONTROL WHAT IS BEING REPORTED TO THE PUBLIC! They control what is told to the media. Which is misrepresenting the facts and misleading the public.
The reason there is a teacher shortage or difficulties retaining teachers from the past is the system itself and these administrators who created and profited from this system. They now are protecting it at any cost. This education system is a DIRECT cause for much of the hopelessness and poverty in these native villages. The poverty and hopelessness has only gotten worse not better for most rural villages throughout Alaska.
IT IS TOO HEAVY A COST when they are helping to cause such hopelessness and poverty. They are depending on the fact nobody is willing to stand up and say enough is enough. Even if the support staff is now filled with “subs” from the Philipines then they are hurting these already very poor communities.
Please forward this letter. Go ask questions. Don’t accept answers that are being used that are hurting these communities. IT IS AN EMERGENCY!
FINAL THOUGHTS
I know there are many very smart, driven, and wonderful young people in EVERY village in Alaska. Lets help give them a future and let them be involved with change! Life to me is simple. ACTIONS speak much louder than words! Go to your schools. Look around. If there was ONE person subbing that is not from your community and a relative of these “emergency teachers” from the PHILIPPINES then that is TOO MANY! If there are even ONE person holding a full time support staff job, that is TOO MANY.
Some schools now have at least 4 that’s right FOUR full time positions that someone in that village is not working or feeding their family. THIS is a FACT. Ask how many people in each village need a job? Just to have food or pay bills or feel like they have purpose in life. This money is being taken from your local economy and given to people who live in new teacher housing in the palaces on the hill.
TOO MANY have given up hope, while these Superintendents and Principals continue not helping these communities. The idea they cannot find people to fill positions is insulting. Even if this is true then ask yourself who’s responsibility to make this part of the communities? The answer is simple. THE SUPERINTENDENT and the HEAD PRINCIPAL. This is not something that can be pawned off as making their assistant principal responsible. These assistant principals are following what they are told and being trained to continue this system. AND yes I have seen this happen in schools in rural Alaska. Go to the schools. Look around.
There are many good educators so don’t take this as a blanket for all the schools. People have learned to survive within this system doing the best they can to help make a difference and changes. I have worked with some excellent Principals. Very few can stay within the system. Some are steering clear of taking the reins knowing what is being asked. It is time to start from the TOP and work our way Down to find those who truly care.
THE ACTIONS speak louder than the propaganda this system has learned to spread like butter on warm toast. They have learned to cross t’s and dot i’s while controlling what is told to the public. Ask questions and don’t take the answers if they are not backed up by the ACTIONS.
When the communities depend and trust these leaders they hire and their school board the BUCK SHOULD STOP THERE! They are the coaches and leaders who have been given the huge task to help create a better future and help these communities get out of their extreme poverty and hopelessness. Are they doing their jobs? The answer is right in front of you. Don’t be afraid to hold them accountable. They make huge amounts of money to come in to your villages. They are paid to HELP, not take. I know this may not be popular but it is a FACT! This not my opinion.
Many of these people come into these areas and believe what I have been told. As I have said I have been told the school board members are hand picked to go along with what the districts want. And they can’t find good help because the natives are lazy etc. I will testify to this. When people are treated by ACTIONS these same people start believing what they are being told and how they are treated.
IT IS THE job of these districts to find and train people from each village to work and be part of this team. These teams have been losing for way too long. Find the right leaders to come in make a difference. IT IS NOT an easy gig. I am confident though it can be done. We need to ask questions and look at this system of failure.
I can go into any village and find over 20 applicants who need jobs. More like over 100. Are they all qualified or trained. Maybe not. BUT that is our responsibility to get this done. Instead we now are accepting this system of failure and only getting more impossible to change.
Those who have not gotten the job done for many years are running this system. They recycle old ideas that NEVER worked in the first place. The whole premiss for these eductional leaders now is to protect it. DON’t take my word. MY ACTIONS SPEAK FOR MYSELF! Go ask the questions in this letter. Go find out the truth.
Send a message to learn more