09/11/2013
Update on continuing work: "SFPD won't allow public oversight of its surveillance work with the FBI, despite high-profile legislation requiring it. In May 2012, the Board of Supervisors unanimously passed the Safe San Francisco Civil Rights Ordinance, which Mayor Ed Lee signed in a photo-op ceremony with Police Chief Greg Suhr and the activists who supported it. They claimed the board's passage of the ordinance ushered in a new era of transparency over the SFPD's previously secretive work with the FBI-led Joint Terrorism Task Force.
"The ordinance basically requires three things," Nasrina Bargzie, a civil rights attorney at the Asian Law Caucus who worked on the measure, told the Bay Guardian. "The first part requires that the Police Department work with the JTTF has to follow the California constitutional rights of privacy, so they're not following the lax standards of the [US] Department of Justice. The second part is that they can no longer enter into any secret agreements with the FBI; it has to go before the Police Commission in a public setting. The final part of the ordinance exists to make sure the rules are being followed, so there is a requirement for a yearly report."
"We have been extremely disappointed at the lack of information that has been included in the reports," Summer Hararah, Regional Director for the Greater San Francisco Area Muslim Legal Fund of America told us. Activists have sparred with Chief Suhr over implementation of the ordinance and its required annual report since at least the beginning of 2013. Deputy Chief John Loftus presented the first report to the Police Commission on Jan. 23, which claimed the SFPD was in "full compliance" with the ordinance without providing any details. Activists and the public quickly demanded a real response. Suhr apologized for the omissions while stating his department was still in compliance with the ordinance's guidelines, pledging to be more forthcoming.
Suhr then released a second report, which contained more relevant information, stating that SFPD officers did not act as informants in 2012 and three full-time SFPD officers were assigned to the JTTF. But the report still omitted key oversight information, such as whether any prosecutions resulted from JTTF and SFPD investigations. "Civil rights is not a symbolic issue," Hararah told us. "The mayor backed this legislation and we want to see that the commitment is put forth. The first step is having info about what the JTTF is doing to be sure it abides by human rights protections and is appropriate."
[email protected] high-profile local civil rights ordinance passed last year to shine light on the San Francisco Police Department's joint activities with the FBI has been undermined by the SFPD's refusal to disclose its surveillance activities. This comes at a time when the public is learning more tha...