01/14/2025
"OUR" LETTER TO:
{& IT HELPS}
December 23, 2024
The Honorable Kathy Hochul
Governor of New York State
NYS State Capitol Building
Albany, NY 12224
Re: Support Modernizing New York’s Returnable Container Act (“Bottle Bill”) as Part of Your
Executive Budget or as a Program Priority, Which Would Increase Redemption Rates, Reduce
Litter, Help Reduce Solid Wastes, and Protect Jobs & Businesses
Dear Governor Hochul,
The undersigned organizations write to express our strong support to modernize New York’s Returnable
Container Act, commonly known as the ‘Bottle Bill.’ It's time to update the law to increase the deposit
value, include popular non-carbonated beverages, wine, spirits, hard cider, and other beverage containers.
Expanding the type of beverages in the Bottle Bill deposit program will result in billions of bottles being
diverted from landfills and incinerators. An expanded Bottle Bill will further reduce pollution, especially
plastic pollution, all while lifting up workers in the recycling and redemption industry.
There are four important steps needed to modernize the law:
Expand the type of covered beverage containers. Modernization expands the types and number of
beverage containers covered by the Bottle Bill. Other states from Maine to California include a diverse
range of non-carbonated beverages, wine, and liquor with great success. Any modernization plan
appropriately exempts all dairy, dairy-like, and 100% vegetable and fruit juice containers.
Increase the amount of the deposit to a dime. The impact of the nickel deposit that was approved in
1982 has eroded over time. A mere inflation update would likely make that deposit nearly fifteen cents. To
ensure that those who wish to redeem their deposits can easily do so, we need a portion of the additional
revenues collected by the state to be used to ensure better compliance and enhance access to redemption
entities. Oregon has already increased deposits on beverage containers to 10 cents, leading to an
immediate increase in recycling redemption rates. An additional benefit is that an increased deposit (plus
an expansion to new containers) will help "canners," those hard-working individuals who collect
redeemable containers that are discarded by the original consumer.
Increase the "handling fee,” which has not been increased in 15 years. The "handling fee" is the
funding stream for redemption centers, entities which exist to make it easier for consumers to redeem
containers as well as helping the state's redemption rate. As you know, the costs of running a business
have significantly increased over the past 15 years, but the funding for redemption centers has not. As a
result, over 100 centers have had to close, thus undermining the program, reducing consumer
convenience, and costing the state jobs. We urge that you include a phase-in increase in the fee as part of
your budget.
Modernization has other benefits as well. The bill’s reuse provisions would reduce single-use plastic
bottles that are made from fossil fuels, bringing it more in alignment with NYSERDA’s Climate Plan by
phasing out single-use packaging. Deposit programs are also much better for glass recycling. The
recovery rates for glass containers under deposit are 2-3 times the rate as they are recycled in curbside
programs. The quality of material is significantly better, without contamination, such that the glass from
the bottle deposit program is virtually all returned to glass container manufacturing plants in New York
and neighboring states in the region.
The above provisions, plus other important reforms, are included in S.237-C/A.6353-A of the 2024
legislative session. We support that bill and urge you to include it as part of your executive budget or
embrace it as a program proposal. As you know, modernization of the law was included as part of the
DEC’s “New York State Solid Waste Management Plan: Building the Circular Economy Through
Sustainable Materials Management (2023 - 2032).”
We urge your support for this important environmental and economic justice initiative. Including the
Bigger, Better Bottle Bill in your FY 2025-2026 Executive Budget or as a program proposal will bolster
the state’s efforts to reduce litter, enhance recycling, create jobs, lift up canners in disadvantaged
communities, expand equity, and ease consumer participation.
Thank you for considering our request, and we look forward to working with you to ensure a cleaner
environment.
Sincerely,
350Brooklyn
350NYC
5 Cent Bottle Return LLC
A&A Redemption Center, Inc
AAJA
ACES Aurorans for Climate and Environmental
Sense
Adirondack Voters for Change
Albany Presbytery Peacemaking Task Force
Albany UU Green Sanctuary Team
Albion Redemption Center
All Our Energy
Allegany Beverage and Redemption
Alliance for a Green Economy
Amir holdings inc
AQS REDEMPTION INC
ARC Redemption Inc.
Auburn Bottle Return
Aytzim: Ecological Judaism
Bag O’ Nickels Redemption
Best Buds @ SU
Beyond Plastics
Beyond Plastics Brooklyn
Beyond Plastics Queens
Beyond Plastics Schenectady
Beyond Plastics Sullivan County NY
Big Reuse
Bottle Bills
BOTTLE DEPOT
Bottle World inc
Bottles For The Brave
BSA Pack 4076
BSA Troop 4085
Buffalo Nickel Redemption
Buffalo Pug and Small Breed Rescue Inc
Buffalos Best Bottles
Burroughs Audubon Nature Club
Buy Local, Grow Local
CAMDEN CANS & BOTTLE RETURN
Camden Cans & Bottle Returns
Campaign for Renewable Energy
Can Stop Redemption Center and Groceries, Inc.
Capital Region Interfaith Creation Care
Coalition (CRICCC)
Cash For Cans Express Corp
Catholic Charities Tompkins/Tioga
Caz Cans LLC
Center for Independence of the Disabled, New
York (CIDNY)
Center for Justice & Democracy
Center for Urban Environmental Reform
Church Women United in New York State
Citizens Concerned About Plastic Pollution
Clean Air Action Network of Glens Falls
Clean Air Coalition of Western New York
CLYNK
CNY Redemption
Coalition for Outreach, Policy & Education
(COPE)
Community Advocates for a Sustainable
Environment
Coins to dollars redemption center
ColorBrightonGreen
Columbia County Reduces Waste--Bring Your
Own (CCRW--BYO)
Community Beverage
Compost International
Corbitt's Corner
Creating Change Redemption Center
D & p recycle inc.
D.C Redemption
Deep Green Resistance New York City
Deignan Institute for Earth and Spirit at Iona
University
Delaware-Otsego Audubon Society
Don’t Trash the Catskills
Duanesburg Redemption Bottle & Can Return
Inc
Earth & Me
Ecojustice Collaborative
Elmirans & Friends Against Fracking
Elmsford Conservation Advisory Council
Environment Ministry of the Church of St.
Francis Xavier in Manhattan
Environmental Action Coalition
Exchange Redemption Inc
Exchange Redemption Inc
Express bottle return
Federated Conservationists of Westchester
County
Five Cents Fast
For the Many
For Your Canvenience
Fridays for Future Capital District NY
Frye Road Redemption Center
Fultonville Redemption Center
Glass Packaging Institute
Gliding Stars Inc
Grassroots Environmental Education
Grassroots Gardens WNY
Greece Baptist Sustainability Team
Green Bottle Redemption Center
Green Education and Legal Fund
GREEN LEGACY EXPRESS INC
Green Map System
Green World 168 LLC
GreeningUSA
GreenLatinos
Greenway Bottle and Can
Groundwork Hudson Valley
Hell's Kitchen Neighborhood Association
Hilltop Redemption
Hudson River Sloop Clearwater
Impact 100 NYC
Indivisible New Rochelle
Indivisible Scarsdale
JK Peris, Inc.
Keep Rockland Beautiful
Lakeshore Bottle & Can Return Center
Lampros Solar
League of Women Voters
League of Women Voters of Cortland County
League of Women Voters of New York State
Liberty Beer Depot Inc.
Livonia Redemption Center
Long Island Bottles and Cans Inc
Lowville redemption center
Mammoth Recycling
Mega Beverage Redemption Center Inc
Midstate Recycling LLC
Mohawk Redemption
MOSAIC
Mothers Out Front Dutchess Count
Mothers Out Front Tompkins
Nassau HIking & Outdoor Club
Neighborhood redemption center
New York Climate Action Group
New York Communities for Change (NYCC)
New York Progressive Action Network
New York Public Interest Research Group
New York State PTA
New Yorkers for Clean Power
Nickel and Dime Redemption Center
Nickel City Bottle and Can Redemption Center
Nickelback Bottle and Can Return
North American Climate, Conservation and
Environment(NACCE)
North Country Earth Action
North Shore Audubon Society
NYCD16 Indivisible
NYenvironcom
Onondaga Audubon
Operation SPLASH
Orange RAP
Orangutan Outreach
Park Slope Neighbors
PAUSE (People of Albany United for Safe
Energy) / 350Albany
People for a Healthy Environment
People for a Healthy Environment
Peoples Climate Movement - NY
Protect the Adirondacks
Putnam Progressives
Quick & Easy Bottle Return
Quick Stop beverage and grocery
Rabideau Redemption
RAFT (Residents Allied for the Future of Tioga)
REDEEMER BOTTLE AND CAN RETURN
CENTER
Residents Allied for the Future of Tioga (RAFT)
RISE (Rockaway Initiative for Sustainability
and Equity)
Rivers & Mountains GreenFaith Circle
RLS Management Solutions LLC
Rochester Area Interfaith Climate Action
(RAICA)
Roctricity LLC
Roseadon Enterprises
Roseadon Enterprises, Inc.
Safe Energy Rights Group
SAPHE
Saratoga Friends Meeting
Save the Pine Bush
Save the Sound
SDIPN! (Shut Down Indian Pt. NOW!)
Seatuck Environmental Association
Seneca Lake Guardian
Shelly's redemption center
Shoulette’s Redemption Depot
Shoulette’s Redemption Depot
Shut Down Indian Point NOW!
Sisters of Mercy of the Americas Justice Team
Sisters of St. Dominic of Blauvelt, New York
Skidmore College Environmental Action Club
Smitty’s enterprises inc
Solarize Albany
Solidarity Committee of the Capital District
South Beach Civic Association
South Shore Audubon Society
St. Francis Xavier Church in Manhattan
Story of Stuff Project
SUNY New Paltz Environmental Task Force
Superior Redemption
Sure We Can
Surfrider Foundation Eastern Long Island
Chapter
Surfrider Foundation New York City
Sustainable Putnam
Sustainable Warwick
Syracuse Cultural Workers
Ten Lives Club
The Environmental Recycling of NY
The Park Church
The Story of Stuff
Third Act Rochester
Third Act Upstate New York
THRIVE (The Healing Resource Institute for
Victim Empowerment)
TIAA-Divest! from climate destruction
Tim Malpo
Tompkins County Climate Protection Initiative
Two-Can Dan's Redemption Center
United Climate Action Network
United for Action
United Jewish Federation of Northeast New
York
United Muslim Alliance of Albany
United University Professions (UUP)
Upper Green Side
Upper Nyack Green Committee
Upper West Side Recycling
UU Congregation of Binghamton, Green
Sanctuary
Valcour Bottle redemption center
Vetrone's Redemption Center
W.I.S.E
WESPAC Foundation, Inc.
Westchester Alliance for Sustainable Solutions
(WASS)
Zero Waste Capital District
Zero Waste Ithaca
Zero Waste Warren County