09/01/2026
We are angry but not surprised by the House of Representative’s reckless decision to push North Atlantic right whales towards extinction. Solutions to reduce entanglements, backed by science, already exist. The only thing HR 9436 accomplishes is denying an endangered species the protection they deserve, for 9 more years.
The bill, sponsored by Representative Mike Lawler (NY) whose district is not coastal, and Maine’s lame duck Representative Jarred Golden, prevents further measures to reduce accidental entanglements to critically endangered North Atlantic right whales until 2035. In 2022, a federal judge ruled that entanglement protections for right whales needed to be in place by December 2024. Later that year, the Maine delegation inserted language into the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 moving the court ordered deadline to December 31, 2028. This bill further delays any protective actions until 2035.
With fewer than 400 North Atlantic right whales remaining today, and accidental entanglements being one of the leading causes of death, we should be legislating protection, not extinction. Studies suggest that 85% of North Atlantic right whales have been entangled in fishing gear at least once. On average, it takes about 6 months for an entangled whale to succumb to their injuries. The life of a North Atlantic right whale should not be one filled with pain, just for existing.
It doesn’t have to be this way.
Over 1 million pounds of seafood has been commercially harvested in the US and Canada using on-demand fishing gear (also known as ropeless gear). This technology works and reduces the risk of entanglements by removing the static vertical line in the water column at times and in places right whales are known to aggregate. This is truly a win-win for the whales and fishing communities, but politics are preventing progress.
When whales die, we all lose.
Whales are a sentinel species who provide insight and understanding in the health of ocean, including North Atlantic right whales. They also stimulate phytoplankton-the base of the entire marine food web- and help the ocean produce oxygen. Protecting whales means protecting everyone’s future, from the coastal fishermen to the people in the Midwest-we all benefit from healthy whale populations.
It doesn’t end here. We will work tirelessly to ensure that the Senate does not pass this bill.