10/03/2026
Thank you to Putnam Press & Times and reporter Holly Crocco for revisiting Andrew Krivak’s case on International Wrongful Conviction Day, and for documenting his release, acquittal and subsequent settlement.
Our Foundation helped assemble the legal team that challenged Andrew’s conviction and represented him at retrial. After approximately 24 years incarcerated, his story underscores the persistence these cases require—and the years no settlement can restore.
We’re grateful for local journalism that follows these cases over time and helps the community understand their lasting consequences. We also remember Josette Wright and her family’s enduring loss.
For Flashback Friday on International Wrongful Conviction Day, we revisit Holly Crocco’s reporting on Andrew Krivak’s Putnam County case.
The case began with the disappearance of 12-year-old Josette Wright in 1994. Her remains were discovered in Patterson the following year.
Krivak was convicted in 1997 and spent approximately 24 years incarcerated before his release pending retrial in 2020. A jury found him not guilty on February 27, 2023.
Attorneys Oscar Michelen and Karen Newirth represented him at retrial. The defense challenged witness testimony and argued that his confession was coerced. The Jeffrey Deskovic Foundation for Justice helped assemble his legal team.
The Foundation’s founder, Jeffrey Deskovic, was himself exonerated through DNA evidence in 2006 after spending 16 years imprisoned for a Westchester murder. His case also had a Putnam connection: a county sheriff’s investigator conducted the polygraph examination during the interrogation that produced his false confession.
Following Krivak’s acquittal, DA Robert Tendy said the jury’s decision must be respected, while maintaining his belief in Krivak’s guilt.
In 2024, Krivak’s civil lawsuit was settled for $20 million, largely covered by insurance. Putnam County’s deductible was $200,000.
Holly’s photo shows his 2020 release from the Putnam County Correctional Facility and accompanied our 2024 settlement story.
Today, we reflect on the consequences of wrongful convictions while remembering Josette and her family’s enduring loss.
2023 acquittal:
https://bit.ly/putnamkrivak23
2024 settlement:
https://bit.ly/putnamkrivak
Reporting and photo: Holly Crocco