10/30/2025
From the Museum:
HIGHLAND HOUSE BURNED
Cottage City Loses Another Large Hotel
Vineyard Gazette
October 26, 1893
Cottage City, Mass October 26th, 3:20am
Only the burning and smoking ember left to mark the spot where yesterday, in all its completeness, stood the popular Highland House.
At 12:20, midnight, the town was aroused from its slumber to witness another conflagration. This time the Highland House was the object upon which all turned their eyes as it stood out on the Highlands bluffs, clearly defined in the light of the moon and the bright flames which enveloped the north-east end and tower, and which, fanned by the strong wind blowing from the north-east, were soon to cause the destruction of the whole building. The alarm was rung in from box 34, at the old “Star office”. The fire was discovered by Mr. Lewis Bartlett and others who were returning from a dance in Vineyard Haven. When first see the blaze was small when compared to the size of the hotel, but before the fire department could cover the long distance the fire was under full headway. But had they been on the spot efforts to save the hotel would have been futile. The best of the burning structure was so intense that the buildings on the opposite side, at the head of the wharf, were scorched, and it was feared at one time that everything from the Highland House to New York avenue would be set on fire by the sparks which were carried over the avenue and rained down upon the houses to the westward of the burning house. The sparks lodged on roofs and ignited, but were put out by citizens and firemen, who were stationed along the line. The house or stock was purchased a short time since Messrs. Clofus Gonyon and A.G. Wesley of Cottage City, and John D. Flint of Fall River. But a small insurance was carried on the house , amounting to $6,000. The house was thoroughly renovated and improved last season at an expense of about $6,000, so that the loss comes very heavy on the owners.
Agassiz Hall was saved by the change of the wind which carried heat and blaze a little on side of it and covered the concrete drive with live sparks.
It was expected that the Selectmen will offer a reward for the conviction of the person or persons who set the fire, for it is the opinion of most of the people that fire is of incendiary origin, and a thorough investigation will be made.
Sheriff Jason L. Dexter left Edgartown for the scene of the fire at 3:30 o’clock this morning, and Deputy T.A. Dester was also sent for later in the morning. An investigation is being made quietly but vigorously.