10/14/2026
On October 13, the Newton Rotary Club learned about the history of Arndt's Fudgery from Lois Lewis (right), who worked for Arndt's for 49 years, only retiring just this past May.
Lewis described how George Arndt started the business in 1913, purchasing a grocery store and converting it to a "five and dime" variety store.
George's son, Bill, assumed responsibility for the business in the 1940's, after he returned from military service, and expanded by opening additional stores in Casey and Greenup.
In 1967, Bill's son Tony, took over, opening more stores in Tuscola, Shelbyville, and Arthur. Always looking for a new product or direction for the business, he added Hallmark greeting cards and gifts, in addition to the school supplies, fabric, and other staple items. Arndt's was there for the fads like Cabbage Patch dolls and Beanie Babies stuffed toys.
They began making fudge, and sales began to take off, helping replace slower sales of cards and gifts. They originally sold it in the store, but as sales increased, they started some real production.
They currently have ten employees, and are taking orders over the internet, as well as Road Ranger stores across the country, to sell many varieties of fudges and brittles, but also Amish-made jams, jellies, and sauces.
On a normal day, they get around 200 orders, and may have twice that many during the holidays. Some huge orders go out, such as 700 pounds to be sold at the Covered Bridge Festival.
With their fudge-making machines, a person can produce about 40 pounds in less than an hour.
Arndt's fudge uses only high-quality, fresh ingredients, and can be purchased locally at Rauch's Jewelry and Gifts, on the SW corner of The Square in Newton.
To find out more, go to www.fudgery.com.
Chairperson for the day was Rotarian Brett Lessley (left).