06/19/2026
Day 12: Article XI – Of the Justification of Man
“We are accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by Faith, and not for our own works or deservings: Wherefore, that we are justified by Faith only is a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort, as more largely is expressed in the Homily of Justification.”
As we continue our journey through the Thirty Nine Articles, we arrive at what many historians consider one of the central theological concerns of the Reformation. Article XI addresses the doctrine of justification, a subject that stood at the heart of many of the debates that shaped sixteenth century Christianity.
Yet before we dive into the historical controversies, it is important to understand what the Article is actually asking.
How can sinful people stand righteous before a holy God?
How are we reconciled to God?
On what basis are we forgiven?
What gives us confidence that we belong to Christ?
These questions are not merely theological exercises. They touch the deepest concerns of the human heart. Every person who has ever wrestled with guilt, failure, weakness, or the fear of judgment has in some way wrestled with the question of justification.
The answer offered by Article XI is both simple and profound.
We are justified not because of our own goodness, merit, or accomplishments, but because of Jesus Christ.
The Article begins with the declaration that we are “accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.”
The key word here is merit.
In the language of the Article, merit refers to that which earns favor before God. The Reformers insisted that no human being possesses sufficient merit to stand before God on his own. Even our best works are imperfect. Even our noblest efforts fall short of the holiness of God.
This is not because human beings are incapable of doing anything good. As we saw in previous Articles, people can perform acts of kindness, charity, courage, and generosity. Yet even these good works cannot erase sin or reconcile us to God.
The Reformers believed that if salvation depended upon our own achievements, no one could be saved.
Instead, Article XI directs our attention entirely toward Christ.
The righteousness by which we stand before God is not something we create. It is something we receive.
Christ lived the life of perfect obedience that we could not live.
Christ died the death that we deserved.
Christ rose again in victory over sin and death.
Therefore, when we place our faith in Him, we are accounted righteous because of His merits rather than our own.
To understand why this became such a major issue during the Reformation, we must remember the spiritual climate of the late medieval Church.
Many ordinary Christians lived with deep anxiety about their salvation. There was often uncertainty concerning whether one had done enough good works, performed sufficient acts of penance, or achieved the necessary level of holiness.
The Reformers feared that many people had begun to place their confidence in their own efforts rather than in Christ.
Article XI was written to redirect that confidence.
Its purpose is not to diminish the importance of holy living. Rather, it seeks to establish the proper foundation for holy living.
We do not obey God in order to earn salvation.
We obey God because salvation has already been given to us through Christ.
This distinction is critical.
The Article famously states that we are justified “by Faith only.”
Those words have generated enormous discussion over the centuries, particularly between Protestants and Roman Catholics.
At first glance, some may wonder whether this statement contradicts passages such as James 2, where we read that “faith without works is dead.”
Historically, Anglicans have generally understood that there is no contradiction.
When Article XI speaks of justification by faith, it is speaking about the basis upon which we are accepted by God.
When James speaks about works, he is addressing the evidence of genuine faith.
In other words, good works do not cause our justification, but they naturally flow from it.
A living faith produces a transformed life.
A faith that never bears fruit raises questions about whether it is truly alive.
The Reformers were therefore not opposing faith and works.
They were opposing the idea that works could earn salvation.
This is one reason why the Article immediately describes justification by faith as “a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort.”
Notice that phrase: “very full of comfort.”
The purpose of this doctrine is not merely intellectual precision.
It is pastoral comfort.
Imagine the burden carried by someone who believes that salvation depends entirely upon personal performance.
How much prayer is enough?
How much charity is enough?
How much holiness is enough?
How much repentance is enough?
The answer is never enough.
If our confidence rests in ourselves, we will always find reasons for fear.
Article XI therefore points us away from ourselves and toward Christ.
The comfort of the Gospel is that our salvation ultimately rests not upon our achievements but upon Christ’s finished work.
This does not lead to complacency.
Rather, it creates freedom.
When we no longer live in fear of earning God’s favor, we become free to love Him more deeply and serve Him more faithfully.
The doctrine of justification therefore leads not to spiritual laziness but to gratitude.
Today, different Anglican traditions often emphasize different aspects of this Article.
Evangelical Anglicans frequently regard Article XI as one of the defining statements of the Reformation. They often emphasize the forensic aspect of justification, the idea that believers are declared righteous because of Christ’s righteousness.
Broad Church Anglicans may focus on the relational dimensions of justification, emphasizing reconciliation with God and transformation within the life of faith.
Anglo Catholics have historically approached the Article somewhat differently than many Evangelicals, but without necessarily rejecting it. Anglo Catholics often emphasize that justification and sanctification are deeply connected. While justification comes through Christ alone, the Christian life involves an ongoing process of growth in holiness through grace, the sacraments, prayer, and participation in the life of the Church.
Indeed, many Anglo Catholic theologians have pointed out that Article XI does not say that good works are unnecessary. It simply teaches that they are not the basis of our justification.
This distinction allows Anglo Catholics, Evangelicals, and many Broad Church Anglicans to affirm the Article while placing emphasis upon different dimensions of the Christian life.
What remains constant is the conviction that salvation is ultimately God’s gift.
This doctrine remains profoundly relevant today.
Modern culture often encourages people to build their identity upon achievement. We are measured by our success, productivity, accomplishments, and performance.
Many people unconsciously carry this mindset into their spiritual lives.
They imagine that God’s love must be earned.
They fear they are not doing enough.
They worry that they are somehow falling short.
Article XI speaks directly into these fears.
The Gospel is not that we climb our way to God.
The Gospel is that God has come to us in Jesus Christ.
The Gospel is not that we save ourselves.
The Gospel is that Christ saves us.
The Gospel is not that we become worthy and are therefore accepted.
The Gospel is that we are accepted in Christ and are therefore transformed.
This is why the Article describes justification by faith as a doctrine full of comfort.
The comfort is not found in ourselves.
The comfort is found in Christ.
When we fail, Christ remains faithful.
When we stumble, Christ remains merciful.
When we doubt, Christ remains steadfast.
When we recognize our sin, Christ remains our advocate.
As Anglicans, whether Low Church, Broad Church, or Anglo Catholic, we confess that our hope rests not in our own righteousness but in the righteousness of Christ.
Our salvation rests not upon what we have done for God, but upon what God has done for us through Jesus Christ.
This truth does not diminish the importance of holy living. Rather, it provides the only secure foundation upon which holy living can be built.
For the Christian life begins, continues, and ends in grace.
And because our justification rests upon Christ’s merits rather than our own, we may live with confidence, gratitude, and hope.
Indeed, as the Article itself declares, this remains “a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort.”
Per Crucem, Ad Lucem, In Fide
Fr. Liam M. Helms
Chancellor and Canon to the Ordinary
The Ordinariate of Saint George for Chaplaincy