McSherrystown Residents The Uncensored Truth

08/30/2026

We officially DOUBLED the amount of pint flavors in our grab & go freezers!

And since some of you start preparing for our winter closure like you’re preparing for the apocalypse, I figured I should let you know what you’re working with. 😂

Here’s what we’ve got:

All Nighter
Apple Pie
Birthday Cake
Brownie Batter
Butter Pecan
Cake Batter
Chocolate
Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Icing
Chocolate Eclair
Chocolate Heartbreak
Chocolate Marshmallow
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Coconut Paradise
Cookie Butter
Cookie Dough
Cookie Monster
Cookies n’ Cream
Espresso
Fluffernutter
Just the Stuff
Key Lime
Mint Oreo
Moose Tracks
Orange Pineapple
Oreo n’ Dough
Peach
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
Peanut Butter Oreo
Peppermint Patty
Raspberry
Raspberry Cheesecake
Red Velvet Cake
Salty Caramel
Salty Peanut Butter Crunch
Sea Salt Cookie Crunch
Strawberry Shortcake
Turtle
You Can Do It, Bruce! (limited time only)
Vanilla

Then starting September 1st, we’ll add:

Pumpkin Cheesecake
Pumpkin Roll
Cinnamon Roll

And since we’re talking about stocking up, here are your closing dates for the season:

New Oxford — October 6
Gettysburg — October 13
McSherrystown — October 20

You’ve got plenty of warning. What you do with your freezer space between now and then is none of my business. 😂🍦

08/29/2026

We are pretty sure they are closing because of lack of sales and the current Sexual Harassment lawsuit, not to mention the horrible owners.

McSherrystown has always had one great Ice Cream Place thats HALF-PINT!!
No one is sorry to see them go!!!

Trying not to cry as I write this… 🥹🍦

This Sunday, our McSherrystown chapter comes to an end. 😢

The picture below is from the night we opened — a wide-eyed Rip with her best buddies by her side. They were all just babies, and Ripleigh’s was the very first job for all of them. ❤️

That opening night was PURE chaos. 😂 Ice cream flying, lines out the door, and a bunch of young kids trying to figure out how to work the milkshake machine.

We had absolutely no idea what we were in for… and we definitely weren’t prepared for the amount of love this community would give us.

And that love never stopped.

This week, so many of you have come in for one last scoop. You’ve shared your stories, your favorite memories, taken that last picture at the IG wall and sampled our wildest flavors one more time.

It’s been such a fun ride. ❤️

We’re not closing McSherrystown because we have to. We’re closing because sometimes you have to make room for the next chapter.
There is a new grandchild to love, new adventures and internships ahead for Rip, and new companies ready to spread their wings and jump into our space. For us, it’s simply time to make room for all of those new chapters to develop.

But before we turn off the lights one last time…

LET’S HAVE A GRAND CLOSING! 🎉

Come see us. Take that last picture. Try one more crazy flavor.

🍦 Friday: 4–9:30 PM
🍦 Saturday: 12–9:30 PM
🍦 Sunday: 12–9 PM

From that crazy first night to our very last scoop… Thank you, McSherrystown. Truly. ❤️

08/07/2026

08/05/2026

There has been nothing but issues, With this woman an her daughter, McSherrystown doesnt need this kind of business.

The boy said he wanted to prepare the homeschooled Catholic girl from Adams County for the real world.

04/11/2026

With Heart In Hand Award nominations are now open! Nominate deserving volunteers in our community for the With Heart In Hand Volunteer Awards. Nominations are due by noon, Friday, May 8th, 2026. https://www.uwadams.org/with-heart-in-hand-2026/

04/11/2026

🎉 Members Appreciation Day 🎉

Join us at McSherrystown Moose Lodge #720 as we celebrate YOU — our amazing members!

🚨 THIS EVENT IS FOR MCSHERRYSTOWN MOOSE MEMBERS ONLY 🚨

Come out for an afternoon of appreciation, great company, and good times at the lodge. We wouldn’t be what we are without our members, and this day is all about saying THANK YOU!

👉 Don’t miss it — we look forward to seeing all of our members there!