05/21/2026
Like mother, like daughter: Caroline (Sheeran) McDermod, ’99 and Ayla McDermod ’28 both earned the Rookie of the Year Honor at Saint Anselm College.
It’s been more than 30 years since Caroline (Sheeran) McDermod ’99 first arrived on the Hilltop, but with every return to campus, she remembers grass-stained uniforms, sweaty cleats, and the beginning of lifelong friendships. The soccer standout was drawn to Saint Anselm’s academic reputation and charm, and she knew it was a place where she could study history while shining on the field. “It was a special four years,” Caroline says.
After attending countless alumni events and cheering on women’s soccer with former teammates, Caroline never could have guessed her daughter would become NE-10 Rookie of the Year, just like her.
Ayla McDermod ’28, a member of the women’s lacrosse team, insists her journey to the Hilltop was her own. She had heard many stories of the college from her parents, but what attracted her to Saint Anselm was a desire to study nursing while playing lacrosse.
During Ayla’s rookie season at Saint Anselm, she started the first game with a hat trick, and led the season in goals scored. Her speed and composure helped the team reach the NCAA Tournament. Soon enough, a new award debuted in the McDermod home: 2025 NE-10 Rookie of the Year.
Both Caroline and Ayla attribute their athletic accomplishments to their teammates’ thoughtful encouragement. While Caroline and Ayla may have chosen different sports on the Hilltop, they arrived at the same conclusion: Being Anselmian changes you. “It’s not just four years; it really is forever,” Caroline says. “You [can] be part of this community at any chapter in your life.”
Read more in the most recent edition of Portraits Magazine: https://www.anselm.edu/about/anselmian-hub/news/alumni-news-fallwinter-2026