06/16/2026
Jane Irene Cutler’s life changed forever on February 15, 1932. The 57-year-old housewife had just lost her husband, Berrien County Sheriff Fred Cutler, ten days earlier after a sudden illness. Now, in an extraordinary transition, she was appointed as his successor, becoming the first and only woman to serve in that post in Berrien County.
As Sheriff, Fred Cutler dealt with some very high-profile cases, including the trial of Fred “Killer” Burke and the arrest of notorious gangster Gus Winkeler, who was wanted for the largest bank robbery in history to that date. After Fred’s shocking death, the Berrien County community rallied to nominate Jane Cutler as the successor to her husband’s office. She served an eleven-month term and handled a record number of inmates—totaling 1,234—that year.
To learn about how Cutler obtained confessions using a motherly disposition, why one inmate chose to stay in the jail under Cutler after his sentence was up, and more, read the FULL ARTICLE “Madam Sheriff: The Unlikely Stry of Jane Irene Cutler” for free athttps://hsmichigan.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/PUB-MHM-Sample%20Story%20-%20MayJun26.pdf