08/29/2026
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Traditional Gayöghó:nǫ⁷ Village (Cayuga Nation) August 28, 2026
The Council of Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers is addressing the recent announcement concerning the appointment of Paul Daugherty as Superintendent of the Cayuga Nation Police Department.
Our concern is not with Mr. Daugherty personally or with his professional qualifications. It is with claims of governmental and police authority being made in the name of the Cayuga people.
The announcement states that Mr. Daugherty assisted with the “reacquisition” of Cayuga Nation properties described as having been “illegally occupied by dissident members.”
The Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers Council rejects that characterization.
Cayuga citizens who oppose or do not recognize the Halftown administration should not be reduced to “dissidents,” nor should longstanding disputes involving Cayuga leadership, land, authority, and jurisdiction be presented to the public as settled fact.
There was no consensus of the Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers Council approving Mr. Daugherty’s appointment or authorizing the current Cayuga Nation Police Department as an institution of the traditional Cayuga government.
The Halftown administration does not speak for or represent the traditional government recognized by the Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers Council.
Land, Authority, and Jurisdiction
The public should also understand an important distinction between the historic 64,015-acre Cayuga reservation and land held in federal trust.
In 2023, the Department of the Interior approved approximately 113.96 acres in Cayuga County for placement into federal trust. Those trust lands are distinct from privately owned property located within the historic reservation boundaries.
The existence of a historic reservation boundary does not, by itself, establish Cayuga Nation ownership of every parcel within it. Likewise, the federal government’s administrative relationship with the Halftown administration should not be portrayed as resolving every question of land ownership, governmental authority, or police jurisdiction.
These are distinct legal and governmental questions and should be treated as such.
The Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers Council does not recognize the current Cayuga Nation Police Department as an institution established through the traditional consensus process of Cayuga leadership, nor do its officers exercise the authority of the Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers Council.
This statement is not a personal attack on Paul Daugherty. It is a clarification of authority, accountability, and consent, and a rejection of language that portrays disputed matters within the Cayuga Nation as settled fact.
We urge the media, public officials, law-enforcement agencies, and the general public to acknowledge these distinctions when reporting on or dealing with the Halftown administration and the Cayuga Nation Police Department.
— Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers Council
Traditional Gayöghó:nǫ⁷ Village (Cayuga Nation)
Media Contact:
Chief Sam George
Council of Condoled Chiefs and Clan Mothers
Email: [email protected]