CCIU 13

09/08/2026

A few years later and still missing.

09/08/2026

Missing people from out of Hancock County Indiana and its surrounding counties.

Newest:
Andrew Agee: A 39-year-old man reported missing from Greenfield after leaving his home in a gray Kia Forte (Indiana plate 167ERZ) in July 2026. [1] (https://www.wthr.com/article/news/local/greenfield-police-asking-for-help-in-finding-missing-39-year-old-andrew-agee/531-04c492ea-cbba-474f-949a-5b48739f1c52)

Haylee Cerna: A 14-year-old reported missing/runaway from Greenfield initially circulated by local police and the Hancock County 911 Center. [1] (https://www.facebook.com/WTHR13/posts/please-share-greenfield-police-are-asking-for-the-publics-help-locating-runaway-/1420314863475092/)

Jacques Pierre: A 56-year-old man from Greenfield reported missing after last being seen leaving work in January 2026.

BURNETT,CARRIE 09/15/1974 GREENFIELD POLICE DEPARTMENT 09/11/2024

CHAMBERS,TROY SHAWN 03/10/2008 CUMBERLAND POLICE DEPT 05/04/2024

HERRERA-ASENCIO,YAKELIN F 06/05/2007 SHELBYVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT 09/07/2019

HERRING,ELIJAH 11/07/2009 CUMBERLAND POLICE 10/28/2023

HOLLOWAY,TERRANCE LOVAN 10/25/1956 SHELBYVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/03/2024

MECHAM,ALEXIS 04/12/2008 NEW CASTLE POLICE DEPARTMENT 09/12/2024

PHIPPS,BROOKLYN by POLICE DEPARTMENT 03/28/1982
PHIPPS,BROOKLYN ALEXIS MARIE 03/16/2007 HANCOCK COUNTY SHERIFFS
DEPARTMENT
04/16/2024

ROBINSON,DARRELL 11/30/1994 GREENFIELD POLICE DEPARTMENT 08/21/2024

ROBINSON,HAYLE MISSING SINCE 8/26/2024

SPRIGGS,WALKER 09/19/1996 CUMBERLAND POLICE 08/14/2024

TORREZ-ORDONEZ,FABIANA 09/23/2004 SHELBYVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT 07/25/2019

VILLARREA-TOLX,DORA MARIA 08/09/1933 HANCOCK COUNTY SHERIFFS
DEPARTMENT
06/01/2007

WHITE,HARMONY 04/17/2009 CUMBERLAND POLICE 09/11/2024

WHITE-HENDRIX,JOHNNY MAX 04/27/2007 GREENFIELD POLICE DEPARTMENT 03/15/2024

WILSON,KEYMONIE 11/18/2010 CUMBERLAND POLICE 04/05/2024

WITHERSPOON,JASMINE 11/07/2007 HENRY COUNTY SHERIFF 09/25/2023

Police said Andrew Agee left his Greenfield home on July 20 around 7 a.m. in his gray Kia Forte.

07/26/2026

Update: FOUND 😪 Tyler Wagaman still missing. Anyone with any leads or more information please call. 202-670-0051

Tyler Wagaman is still missing. Can you help?

Tyler’s phone last pinged in Owen County off of Holly Brook Road in Gosport.

He was last heard from on June 15th and has not made any calls or texts and no bank activity.

Tyler drives a black 2003 Ford F150. He has an Indiana blackout plate.

Plate number :
TK945OXP

License plate scanned at Mann near Hadley Rd June 15 @ 330am

License plate scanned at Kentucky rd and Mann rd at lynhurst June 15 at 4:23am.

If you see something - say something, call police. If you know anything his brother is desperate for answers.

07/26/2026

Tell us about the missing and unsolved of Indiana Cases that haven’t received enough attention, those who seem to be forgotten and those who keep you up at night.

Awareness starts with those willing to say their names.

Say their names

05/21/2026

New on the blog: THE NAMES, WITNESSES AND TIMELINE — a detailed look at the people and sequence surrounding the Nancy Lyons case. Read witness lists, timelines and context that help piece the story together. Read more: https://wix.to/y1UmEnW

THE NAMES: • The victim: Nancy Lyons, 46, of Carthage, Indiana • Sister: Beverly Lyons Tallent, of Louisville, Kentucky • Sister and Brother-in-Law: Debora and Rollin Mitchell, of Carthage, Indiana • Carthage Manor Neighbor: Pam Hiner • Carthage Manor Manager Neighbor: Linda Boedicker • ...

05/20/2026

NANCY KAY LYONS, CARTHAGE, INDIANA
QUESTIONABLE ACCIDENT IN RUSHVILLE, INDIANA ON 6/17/2002

As we were surfing many newspaper articles on the day Nancy Kay Lyons went missing to later murdered...we try to learn as much as we could about Nancy, her abduction, and murder…we did in fact come across something. Maybe it's just a coincidence? Or is it? On June 21st 2002, Rushville’s Republican newspaper reports such incidents, known as the “Police Blotter” in the daily newspaper. With no time stamp on 6/17/2002 and no available incident report today in concerns to a 3 vehicle accident heading south on SR 3 on the night Nancy went missing we feel this is something that should have been looked into decades ago. Individuals involved were both living in or on church property at the time of this incident. 3rd car fled the scene with a witness being injured. This is public information and very common for small towns to publish accidents, incidents, and arrests. *Disclosure: We are not accusing anyone, just showing what was reported that was already public knowledge in this blog.: https://wix.to/DcSXFAM 🕯️📚

https://newspaperarchive.com/rushville-republican-jun-21-2002-p-2/

If you have information or memories to share, please reach out. Help keep Nancy’s story alive and honor her memory.

05/01/2026

We remember Nancy Kay Lyons in Carthage, Indiana for the life she lived, not only the tragedy that touched her family. I’m sharing a human-centered profile of Nancy — her years as a devoted nanny, the hobbies that brought her joy, and the messages left by loved ones — to honor her memory and restore the person behind the headlines. Read more and join the conversation at https://wix.to/2DVrV2B Please share respectfully and contact authorities if you have information.

03/17/2026

Neighbors Remembering Nancy Lyons, Carthage, Indiana: How You Can Help Nancy’s Case — We need your eyes and voices. This is a 24 year old cold case with no action. Visit our secure intake hub at https://wix.to/nxrCXEW to view/read our blog on the murder of Nancy Kay Lyons in Carthage, Indiana to submit tips, photos, or documents that could move this investigation forward. In this particular 17 different blogs read the one called "What are the Chances?" and give us your thoughts? Every lead matters; please check your old photos and messages, and report anything that might help. Thank you for standing with our community.

09/25/2025

Did you know from 1974 to 1996 over 40 men had gone missing? Is any of these men a victim to the known serial killer Herbert (Herb) Baumeister? Prehaps some may be unearthed and discovered in his yard or the wooded area of the home...
It is important to do the your DNA in order for these missing family members to become discovered.