09/21/2025
The Seafood Throwdown winner this year, after a hard fought battle, was Tyler Naughton of Toucana Grill. Hatteras. Lord, y'all. They tied last year. We rematched. They TIED AGAIN. The official rules say if that happens, the crowd decides some way. Emcee Blake called on a local commercial fishman to do a taste and make the call. He called it for Tyler stating that the traditional preparation of the mystery fish sold it for him. The mystery fish was... jumping mullet. Never had it but supposedly distinctive and delicious, did Jeffrey's Seafood kick off a new fad? It sure never looked more fancy than presented to the judges this afternoon! We want to thank ALL who participated and especially those from Toucana Grill and Chef Brandyn at Froggy Dog in Avon!