10/26/2026
Heritage Hill Events Featured at Greensburg Rotary Meeting
Emily Manship of Heritage Hill Events was the featured speaker at the Monday, Oct. 26 meeting of the Rotary Club of Greensburg, Club 3437, District 6580.
Manship shared the fascinating story of transforming the former St. Mary's Church campus in Greensburg into Heritage Hill Events, a wedding and special event destination that blends the property's historic character with modern amenities.
Manship also offered Rotarians a glimpse into exciting plans for additional development and future opportunities at Heritage Hill Events.
What began as a conversation about finding the perfect wedding venue has grown into an ambitious historic preservation and redevelopment project that is bringing new visitors, investment, and opportunities to Greensburg.
A Greensburg native who attended St. Mary's School from preschool through sixth grade, Manship explained that her professional journey originally took her in a very different direction.
Coming from a family with strong ties to the medical profession, she earned a nursing degree from Xavier University in Cincinnati and went on to build a 20-year career in healthcare, including work as a nurse and later with Medtronic, where she helped support clinical trials involving an experimental heart valve.
But an entirely different career opportunity began taking shape while she and her husband, Evan, were planning their own wedding 10 years ago.
Manship wanted a traditional, elegant wedding in Greensburg, but the couple struggled to find a local venue that offered the classical atmosphere they envisioned. They eventually held their wedding in Cincinnati.
Meanwhile, the former St. Mary's Church property had become available for purchase.
What began as a running joke between the couple about turning the historic church into a wedding venue eventually became a serious possibility as the property's asking price continued to decline.
The couple purchased the campus in late 2021, including the former church, rectory, school building and education center.
After approximately a year of planning, zoning, state approvals and architectural preparations, construction began in January 2023. Heritage Hill Events hosted its first wedding that August.
Working with local contractor Kevin Richards Construction and other area tradespeople, the Manships focused on preserving the historic character of the former church while adapting it for modern celebrations.
The soaring ceilings, tall windows and architectural features were retained, while a dramatic hickory staircase was installed where the former balcony had been located. That staircase has become one of the venue's most recognizable features.
The initial renovation also included the former education center, which now provides gathering areas, a catering kitchen and bridal suites, along with the outdoor courtyard lawn.
Manship said the business hosted approximately 11 weddings during its first season and has experienced remarkable growth since then.
Today, Heritage Hill Events is fully booked for weddings through 2028.
Much of that success, she explained, comes from Greensburg's geographic location between Indianapolis and Cincinnati.
Couples from both metropolitan areas have discovered that Greensburg offers a convenient meeting point for families and guests, along with a classical wedding setting at a potentially lower cost than comparable venues in larger cities.
The venue has also expanded its services, including obtaining a liquor license and operating its own bar. Clients continue to have the flexibility to select outside catering services.
The second major phase of redevelopment involved the former rectory, which has been transformed into an overnight accommodation facility known as The Inn.
The renovated building features nine bedrooms and seven bathrooms and is available as a single rental property.
Wedding parties and families can reserve the building for an entire wedding weekend, while other groups may rent the property when it is not being used by wedding clients.
Manship acknowledged that renovating the historic rectory proved even more challenging than the original chapel project, but the additional accommodations have become an important part of the overall business.
Among the new developments Manship shared with Rotarians was a planned conservatory on the venue's courtyard lawn.
The glass-and-steel structure would provide a covered, outdoor-style setting for wedding ceremonies, receptions and cocktail hours while offering protection from Indiana's unpredictable weather.
Manship said the project, which she described as an intermediate phase of the property's expansion, is tentatively planned for spring 2027.
An even larger project involves the former St. Mary's school building, which contains approximately 34,000 square feet.
Manship said the long-vacant structure has experienced deterioration and vandalism over the years, but engineering evaluations indicate that it remains structurally salvageable.
Rather than demolishing the building, the owners intend to restore and repurpose it.
Plans call for transforming the former gymnasium into a distinctive indoor event environment featuring large trees, a fountain and landscaping designed to create the appearance of an outdoor setting.
Former classroom areas would be converted into additional overnight accommodations.
When completed, the expanded campus could eventually accommodate approximately 75 overnight guests.
Manship credited partnerships with the City of Greensburg and local economic development representatives, along with READI and Lilly Endowment Initiative funding, for helping move the redevelopment plans forward.
She emphasized that preserving these historic structures is an important part of the project's mission.
Manship also discussed another redevelopment effort involving a former bank building near downtown Greensburg's 1822 alley.
The Manships acquired the property through a partnership involving the city and have already completed significant exterior stabilization work.
While the building's ultimate purpose has not been determined, Manship said several possibilities are under consideration.
Among ideas being considered are an upscale restaurant, w**e or bourbon bar, private dining facilities and space for wedding rehearsal dinners.
The historic bank vault remains intact and would be preserved as a distinctive architectural feature.
Another possibility involves creating dining space that connects directly with the 1822 alley helping encourage additional pedestrian activity and supporting surrounding businesses.
The building's upper floor, which formerly housed office suites, could eventually be used for offices, short-term lodging or another complementary purpose.
Manship stressed that these concepts remain preliminary and that she hopes to gather additional community input before determining the property's final use.
Throughout her presentation, Manship emphasized the importance of Greensburg's downtown revitalization efforts.
She said wedding guests traveling from Indianapolis, Cincinnati and other communities frequently compliment the city's downtown district and its walkability.
Heritage Hill Events encourages guests to visit local coffee shops, restaurants and other businesses during their stays.
Rotarians also discussed downtown parking concerns, particularly as additional housing and redevelopment projects bring more residents and visitors into the area.
Manship acknowledged that parking is an ongoing consideration for larger events and said the business continues exploring ways to accommodate guests while supporting the broader downtown community.
In one of the more personal moments of her presentation, Manship announced that she had resigned from her position with Medtronic just two weeks earlier to devote her full attention to Heritage Hill Events and its future expansion.
After nearly two decades in healthcare, she described the decision as bittersweet but necessary as the business continues to grow.
She explained that her work in medicine and historic redevelopment share a common motivation: improving something that needs care and attention.
Whether helping patients improve their health or restoring buildings that hold special meaning for a community, Manship said she finds fulfillment in making things better.
The career change will also allow her to spend more time with her husband and their two young children while overseeing the business and its upcoming projects.
Her presentation illustrated how entrepreneurial vision, historic preservation and community partnerships can work together to create new economic opportunities while protecting important pieces of Greensburg's history.
For more information about Heritage Hill Events and its ongoing projects, visit https://heritagehillevents.com/ or follow the business on Facebook and Instagram.
The Rotary Club of Greensburg meets Mondays at noon at The Branch Gathering Place and Coffee House in Greensburg.
-30-