06/19/2026
Captain Andersen and his crew were confined in cells at the police station until 7:00 that morning of June 19th, at which point they were hauled out and charged with drunkenness and disorderly conductβwhich they vehemently denied and refused to sign a written statement of guilt. They were then transported to the Butler Street Police Court, where they were thrown into a holding cell with about another dozen prisoners.
Rasmussen recalls, βWe were packed solid. The air was so foul we had difficulty breathing, and the company was far from the best. We had to share our fate with the dregs of Brooklyn." After a long wait--during which several fainted from the heat--the men were brought before Judge James Tighe, who, after treating them in a "very haughty and taunting way" as they pleaded not guilty to all the charges, grudgingly released them on $200 bail each.
Captain Andersen was indignant over his arrest and imprisonment, later stating: "If I had not been under engagement to attend Mayor Gilroy's reception (later that day) I would have gone straight from that police court to the ππͺπ¬πͺπ―π¨ and I would have turned her around and sailed her back to Norway."