09/28/2026
🇺🇸 MEET US MONDAY — MEET ANTHONY! 🇺🇸
This week, we’re getting to know Anthony Carpenter, a longtime reenactor whose journey into the hobby started after seeing his brother, Brian, at an N-SSA shoot. Decades later, the two are still at it—although Anthony freely admits that when it comes to different eras, he tends to follow wherever Brian leads.
From the Civil War to the French & Indian War, the American Revolution, the Jacobite Rebellion, and even the War of 1812, Anthony has collected a lifetime of experiences, friendships, and some apparently very questionable stories involving his brother and a potato.
Let’s meet Anthony!
• Your brother Brian got into reenacting first, and you followed a few years later. What finally convinced you to join him, and what do you remember about your first events?
When I saw Brian at an N-SSA shoot, I wanted to be a part of it. I was still in high school, so I started saving money to get equipped. College got in the way, but I finally got everything together. By then, Brian was fully reenacting, so I followed him into the 137th New York and never looked back.
• Before Brian dragged you into all of this, were you already interested in history, or did reenacting create that interest for you?
Believe it or not, it was books my parents bought me. The American Heritage Junior Library series covered all different historical topics. I read every single one of them multiple times, and I was hooked. I still have close to a full set.
• Do you remember your first impression and kit? Looking back now, how historically accurate—or wonderfully inaccurate—was it? 😂
With Brian’s gentle “guidance,” I was steered toward accurate gear. That guidance continues to this day, and I’m actually very grateful for it. It has saved me from farbiness more than once.
• You’ve been reenacting for decades and have explored more than one period of history. What different eras and impressions have you done over the years?
Well, I follow where Brian leads… Civil War, French & Indian War, Revolutionary War, and even a few Jacobite Rebellion events and one War of 1812 Grand Tactical.
• Of all the periods you’ve reenacted, is there one that has always felt most like “home” to you? Why?
I have a special affection for the Civil War, having several ancestors who participated. I also made some great friends there.
I don’t miss all that traveling to Virginia and Tennessee, though!
• You and Brian have been doing this together for an awfully long time. What has it been like having your brother alongside you for so much of your reenacting life?
It has brought us much closer. Living in different cities, we may not have been able to spend as much time together as we do now through reenacting.
• Brian described your years together as involving plenty of fun, laughs, and occasionally griping about event organizers and farbs. 😂 From your perspective, what are the Carpenter brothers like at a reenactment together?
I think we’re known for our wit—sometimes inappropriate, but never mean or malicious. We both enjoy camp life and the camaraderie.
• Since we’ve already heard Brian’s side, this is your opportunity: What’s a reenacting story involving your brother that he probably hoped you wouldn’t tell us?
All you need to do is ask him about the 125th Antietam, the Berdan Sharpshooters, and a potato.
I still laugh out loud at that.
• Of all the large anniversary events, battles, historic sites, and trips you’ve experienced over the years, which one still stands out most clearly in your memory?
To this day, a few events stand out: the 125th anniversary series of Civil War events, the 250th French & Indian War event at Fort Niagara, and, more recently, the excellent 250th Boston Tea Party event that Brian and I had the privilege of participating in.
• What’s one of those moments when everything came together—the setting, the people, the sounds, the atmosphere—and for a little while it genuinely felt like you had stepped into another time?
At the 125th Gettysburg, our unit was lying down just behind the Angle as 40 Union artillery pieces fired over our heads at the advancing Confederate infantry lines.
Just awesome!
• These days, what’s your favorite part of an event: getting onto the battlefield, talking with the public, camp life, seeing longtime friends, evenings around the fire, or something else?
Having been a teacher in the past, talking with youngsters is great. And, of course, I love the evenings in camp around the fires with your reenacting family.
• You’ve watched generations of reenactors come into the hobby. What do you enjoy about seeing younger and newer members getting excited about living history?
I’m happy to see that the hobby will continue on when the Old Guard has moved on.
• What advice would you give someone who wants to start reenacting today—especially before they start spending money on clothing and equipment?
Research, research, and then get in with a good group of folks—like Alden’s!
• What’s something about reenacting that people looking in from the outside probably don’t understand until they’ve actually spent an entire weekend in camp?
“Why do we do this?”
The wool clothes during the summer, sleeping in tents with no floors, and all the other inconveniences—those are part of what makes the experience grand and glorious to those of us who love it.
• After all these years, what keeps you packing everything up and coming back for another event?
Brian. To spend time with him, my nephews, and all of our Alden’s friends.
• If you could describe reenacting in one sentence, what would it be?
Reenacting takes hold of you, gets inside of you, and gives you memories for a lifetime.