10/11/2026
Stephen Hawking spent a long time arguing that black holes destroy information, and in 2004 he conceded that they don't. In 2012 Anil Ananthaswamy wrote for us about Steve Giddings, a physicist who agreed with Hawking's concession but thought it left some fairly important stuff unanswered. If the information survives, it has to get out of the black hole somehow, and Giddings argued that our usual picture of spacetime doesn't allow it.
In 2025 Physics Magazine put the same question to 1,675 of its readers and American Physical Society members. What they said is on the last slide.
Carousel by Gabe Fitzpatrick.