Misfits Theater Group Dayton

05/09/2026

Meet Spice and Sugar Coffey - twins, born on a "twos"day!

Spice is all about the 'rambunctious' side of life in Dayton. Whether she’s causing a ruckus at the Pony Expresso or giving her sister a hard time, you can be sure she's giving the Mayor and Honey some grief.

While her sister Spice is out looking for trouble, Sugar is busy being the perfect picture of virtue. She’s kind, she’s quiet, and she’s always got a helpful word for anyone who looks like they’re about to faint (which is just about everyone in Dayton lately).
...
Spice is played by Kelli Jo, a Dayton resident who takes her coffee with cream. Her favorite Misfits memory was watching Santa do his sobriety check in last year's "Twas the Night Before Christmas." She would have loved being a Pony Express rider back in the Wild West days!

Sugar is played by Carson City resident Karen Kaslmaryk. She takes her coffee with cream and sugar and would have been a saloon girl in the Wild West. Her favorite Misfits memory was participating in a dance sequence in the Egyptian play back in 2021!

You have one last chance to see the twins and the rest of the crew this Sunday, May 10th at 2PM at The Odeon! Tickets are $15 at the door.

05/07/2026

Mom doesn’t want another coffee cup. She wants a day at the bar! 🍻

Spend Mother’s Day at The Odeon in Dayton with the Misfits for “The Pony Expresso” - the punniest melodrama in the west! 🤠

Sunday, May 10th
2PM

Tickets are $15 at the door.

Email: [email protected] to reserve your seats early!

05/07/2026

Meet FiFi Latte, the glamorous—if slightly confused—right-hand woman to the dastardly Mo Cabana!

FiFi brings a touch of international mystery to Dayton, though no one in town can quite pinpoint where she’s actually from. Is she European? Tropical? Just a little lost? Come see if FiFi can stay focused long enough to help Mo finish his scheme.

…

FiFi is played by Carson City resident, Terri Karlsson, who takes her coffee black. Her favorite Misfits memory was playing a wacky waitress in “Gold Casino” because the character was just so much fun! She thinks she would have made an excellent ‘madame’ back in the Wild West days due to her top-tier management skills. 😉

You have one final chance to see FiFi and the rest of the crew this Sunday, May 10th at 2PM at The Odeon!

Email: [email protected] to reserve. Tickets are $15.

05/02/2026

No Misfits were (permanently) harmed in the making of this production.

Come see Buck Brawn and Mo Cabana duke it out during our second show of “The Pony Expresso” tonight at 7PM at The Odeon.

Tickets are $15 at the door. See you soon! 🤠🍻

05/01/2026

Make it a date and grab dinner at the amazing Stone & Skillet at The Odeon before the show tonight! 😋

🎭 TONIGHT at 7 PM — The Pony Expresso!
Join us at Stone & Skillet inside The Odeon for an evening of laughter, love, and a little caffeine‑fueled chaos as The Misfits Theater Group takes the stage!

✨ Enjoy dinner, drinks, and a show — the perfect Friday date night in Dayton.
Our Date Night Dinner Features are on the menu, and the curtain rises at 7 PM sharp.

🍷 Come early, grab your table, and settle in for a night of great food and unforgettable theater.

05/01/2026

POV: You’re the villain, and you just walked into the Pony Expresso.

Come help us boo the villain and see if our hero can brew up enough trouble to stop his schemes for good! ☕️

TONIGHT at The Odeon at 7PM!

🎟️Tickets are $15 at the door. See you there!

04/30/2026

Meet Mayor Rich Coffey, the man trying his best to keep Dayton together while his own nerves are falling apart! Being the Mayor of a town hit by a mysterious fainting epidemic is hard enough, but it’s nothing compared to the true challenge of his life: raising his twin daughters, especially when his wife Honey goes down with the same symptoms affecting the rest of the town. 😵‍💫

…

Mayor Coffey is played by Misfit and Dayton resident, Mike Timmerman! He takes his coffee black and really enjoyed playing Rudolph in “Twas the Night Before Christmas” last December. He would have liked to be John Wayne’s sidekick and gopher back in the Wild West days!

Come see if Mayor Coffey can help save the town and the local caffeination station, the Pony Expresso!

Tickets still available for May 1, 2, and 10th! Email [email protected] to reserve. Tickets are $15 at the door.

04/29/2026

Clear the way! Barb Dwyer is coming through on her trusty horse, Java! 🐎

While everyone else is worried about the Pony Expresso, Barb is busy representing the Sweet-N-Lo ranch with more energy than a triple-shot latte. She’s loud, she’s proud, and she’s got all the knee-slappin’ jokes you can handle.

…

Barb is played by Andra Woolman, our second-to-longest standing Misfit at 22 years! A resident of Stagecoach, Andra takes her coffee with cream and agave, and would have enjoyed being a saloon girl at the local watering hole back in the Wild West days. Her favorite Misfits memory was directing the play “Murder Most Fouled Up” in 2011, where her son Jason took the stage as an old man and had his wig fly off mid-performance! Like a true thesbian, he played it off and the audience got a big kick out of it.

Andra can’t wait to see you this coming weekend at The Odeon!

Tickets are still available for the May 1, 2, and 10 shows. Email: [email protected] for reservations.

04/28/2026

Meet Buck Brawn, the man who puts the 'hero' in 'heroic.' 💪 Buck isn’t just here to look good in a Stetson - he’s on a mission to solve the mysterious fainting disease sweeping through Dayton.

As temporary sheriff, he’s the only thing standing between the villain and the downfall of the Pony Expresso. Will he save the day and win the heart of Star Bright, or will Mo Cabana leave him in the dust?

…

Buck is played by Misfit James Fakkema from Carson City. He takes his coffee with half-n-half, and LOTS of it. James would have been tending bar during the Wild West days, befriending patrons and keeping the place safe. His favorite Misfit memory is being part of his first play, “Meet the Weavers.”

Come grab a pint (or two 😉) and watch Buck take on Mo Cabana at The Odeon this Friday or Saturday at 7PM!

Tickets are still available - email [email protected] to reserve.

04/28/2026

Meet Mo Cabana, the man with the sharpest mustache and the shadiest business soul in Dayton.

Known for his signature evil laugh, Mo is the owner of The Cabana Coffee Cart and the mastermind behind the chaos at the Pony Expresso. He’s got the schemes, he’s got the cape, and he’s got a heart as black as a double-shot of espresso.

…

Mo is played by long-time Misfit, Kwas! A resident of Carson City, Kwas isn’t much of a coffee drinker. His favorite Misfits memory is his first show back in 2018, “Sp’Getty Anyone?”, where he got to meet everyone and became a part of the crew. As much as he’s been a little type cast as the evil villain on stage, Kwas would have been a “pinkerton” good-guy back in the Wild West days.

…

Come help us boo Mo right out of The Odeon saloon May 1, 2, or 10th!

Email: [email protected] to reserve your seats.

04/26/2026

Dee Caff, isn’t your average aunt. As co-owner of the Pony Expresso, she has dedicated her life to keeping Dayton caffeinated, but between Mo Cabana’s scheming and her customers mysteriously fainting, she’s in a serious bind.

She is fighting to keep the steam rising and the beans roasting before the villains try to shut them down.
…

Dee is played by Cindy Pardini, a Carson City resident and long-time Misfit. She takes her coffee black (or with a little Bailey’s 😉) and would have taken on an Annie Oakley persona back in the Wild West days.

Come cheer for Dee as she tries to brew up a victory at The Odeon!

Email: [email protected] to reserve your seats for our remaining shows: May 1, 2, and 10.