07/15/2026
An enigmatic inscription carved in a wall of the historic Ivey-Ellington House was a long-hidden secret and a mystery which led to a challenging quest to determine its origin and meaning. During the course of the rehabilitation and restoration of the house, work on an interior wall revealed letters and the date July 17th, 1882 carved in the original plaster.
After being apprised of the discovery, Kris Carmichael, Supervisor of Historic Properties, Town of Cary, sent a message to Friends member Carla Jordan Michaels with the words, “I have a mystery for you”. A Cary native with deep roots in Cary going back generations, Carla was well versed in local history, as well as having excellent and extensive historical research skills. Carla shared the information with Barbara Wetmore, another Friends member, who was also very engaged in local historical research activity with Carla.
Many research sources were consulted, many avenues were explored, and hours were spent trying to ascertain the meaning of the inscription and whose name it might be, but the answer remained elusive. Then one night, after a long day, and feeling tired and blurry-eyed as she described it, Carla decided to take another look at the text and happened to minimize it instead of increasing its size. As Carla stared at the screen, she suddenly realized the script resolved to “C A Creel”. As Carla put it, it was a " eureka moment!”. It was a name, and it was the key to unlocking the mystery!
From that moment on, research in a different direction ensued, and the pieces quickly started to fall into place. Historical records research revealed John W Creel, a brick mason who likely was involved with the construction of the Ivey-Ellington house, had a son, Charles A Creel. John W Creel was a Cary resident at the time and actively involved with Cary. He was a stockholder in Cary High School and a member of the Masonic Lodge, as well as being engaged in other organizations.
An 1880 historical record shows Charles A Creel, 19, as a brick mason in the Cary Township. Brick masons often worked with plaster, as well. It was determined that young Charles had probably worked on the construction of the home along with and under the supervision of his father and had inscribed his name and the July 17th, 1882 date in the plaster.
Records further revealed that Charles Creel married in 1881 and lived in Cary. Sadly, Charles passed away suddenly of what was believed to have been “heart disease” at the age of 23. In 1884. His daughter, Charlie, named for her Father, was the child he never knew - born not long after his passing.
Aware of the historical significance of the inscription, measures were taken to ensure its protection and preservation as part of the Ivey-Ellington house restoration. Free public docent-led tours of the first-floor of the Ivey-Ellington House at 310 South Academy Street in Downtown Cary are available weekly on Wednesday afternoons from 12-2. Visitors will be able to see firsthand the mysterious inscription in plaster “C A Creel “ with the accompanying “July 17th, 1882” date.
A video of a live presentation by Carla Michaels and Kris Carmichael, "A Mystery in Plaster at the Ivey-Ellington House”, can be viewed on the Friends YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeuzzNUAHrk
You can also read Carla Michael’s blog, “An Ivey-Ellington House Mystery Encased in Plaster “ in the “Discover Cary History – Blog Posts” section on the Friends of the Page-Walker website:
https://friendsofpagewalker.wildapricot.org/Cary-Me-Back/13500401