Carmel Clay History Museum

Carmel Clay History Museum The Carmel Clay History Museum collects, preserves, and interprets the history of Carmel.

The Carmel Clay Historical Society (CCHS) was formed in 1975 by a group of local residents as part of the nation’s Bicentennial celebration and dedicated the study of Carmel and Clay Township’s history. That same year the City of Carmel gave the historic 1883 Monon Railroad Depot to the society, which it maintains today as a museum of local history.

2024 marks another significant milestone; the g

rand opening of the Carmel Clay History Museum – a community resource dedicated not only to preserving our community’s history, but also a welcoming environment where everyone can connect with the stories that shape Carmel. Museum Hours:
Wednesday-Saturday: 10am-6pm
Sunday: 12pm-5pm

The Carmel Clay Historical Society enriches the lives of residents and visitors
through education and engagement in our community’s vibrant history. CCHS is committed to:
-sharing the authentic history of our community;
-engaging our diverse community in the relevancy and impact of local history;
-serving as an educational resource for our community; and
-curating, preserving, and stewarding the community’s historical collections

Carmel was almost Richland, sort of…The Quaker community that established Carmel predates the town’s founding by six yea...
08/26/2026

Carmel was almost Richland, sort of…

The Quaker community that established Carmel predates the town’s founding by six years. In 1831, nine families met in an abandoned cabin on Benjamin Mendenhall’s land and soon organized a meeting. Mendenhall suggested the name Richland, after the meeting he had belonged to in Greene County, Ohio. Since Quaker towns often shared the name of their meeting, Richland seemed a likely choice. Instead, the town became known as Bethlehem, and later Carmel. In 1891, the Richland Meeting followed suit, adopting the town’s name and becoming Carmel Friends Church.

Though Carmel never became Richland, our high school did for a brief time. That’s right, Carmel High School was known as Richland High School during the early 1870s and again in the mid-1880s. In 2022, the street bordering the school’s west side was renamed Richland Avenue in honor of the Richland Meeting community that helped found both the school and the town.

Visit the museum and explore our exhibit “Why Carmel?” to learn more about how our city was named.

Why is our city called Carmel? After years of research, we finally found the answer.Many of you know that our town was o...
08/21/2026

Why is our city called Carmel? After years of research, we finally found the answer.

Many of you know that our town was originally called Bethlehem. When residents applied for a post office in 1846, however, they needed a different name because another post office by that name already existed in Indiana.

According to town lore, Elizabeth Peelle suggested Carmel after hearing about a heated debate over what to call the post office. Inspired by biblical descriptions of Mount Carmel, she proposed the name to her husband, William, who brought it to the next meeting.

It’s a lovely story, but also not true. When we investigated the story in 2022, we discovered that Elizabeth was still a teenager living in North Carolina in 1846. She and William did not marry until 1850 and did not move here until 1862.

Another early resident, Levi Haines, has also been credited with choosing the name. Haines was an influential figure in the community. He was also the town’s only merchant, and the new post office was to be located in his store. But one question remained: Why Carmel?

While researching our new exhibit, we finally found the connection.
Haines grew up in Columbiana County, Ohio, where his family belonged to a Quaker meeting called Carmel. Quakers often reused the names of their former meetings when establishing new ones. When Bethlehem needed a name for its post office, Haines proposed a name already familiar to him—Carmel.

So our city ultimately takes its name from a small community in eastern Ohio. The town there is now called Rogers, although nearby East Carmel, Ohio, still carries the name.

Come learn the story in our new exhibit, which has another unusual twist—nothing on display is from Carmel, Indiana! Instead, the exhibit brings together artifacts from other places and institutions around the world that share our name.

We’ll be sharing more surprising stories about the name Carmel in the coming weeks, so stay tuned!

Congratulations to Carmel Clay Parks & Recreation on 35 years! Thank you for enhancing quality of life in our community,...
08/20/2026

Congratulations to Carmel Clay Parks & Recreation on 35 years! Thank you for enhancing quality of life in our community, preserving our natural environment, and creating spaces for everyone to enjoy!

Stop by the museum this week to see our newest exhibit!Have you ever wondered how Carmel got its name? One story says th...
08/18/2026

Stop by the museum this week to see our newest exhibit!

Have you ever wondered how Carmel got its name? One story says that a weaver named Elizabeth Peelle was inspired by descriptions of Mount Carmel in the Bible and suggested the name for the town’s post office in 1846. Another says that Levi Haines, the town’s lone merchant, suggested the name. But where did Levi get the idea?

Our new exhibit uncovers the answer! You’ll also discover other cities, towns, schools, companies, artists, celebrities, and more that share the name. Come explore the surprising story of CARMEL!

New Shirts Just Dropped!! Stop by the museum and get yours today for $25!
08/18/2026

New Shirts Just Dropped!! Stop by the museum and get yours today for $25!

The catastrophic flooding that occurred this weekend has been compared to the Great Flood of 1913. That flood followed t...
08/16/2026

The catastrophic flooding that occurred this weekend has been compared to the Great Flood of 1913. That flood followed two weeks after a fire burned down much of the business district along West Main Street and North Rangeline Road. It was a rough month for our little town.

On March 23, heavy rain and high winds battered Carmel, knocking over trees and outbuildings. The rain continued for the next four days. White River rose rapidly and flooded its banks on the night of March 24, forcing many to evacuate their homes. After midnight, a distress call was received in Carmel from Hugh Moffitt, whose family was trapped on the second story of their home in the vicinity of Eller’s Bridge. Residents rescued them in rowboats and took them back to town, which had gone dark after the storm knocked out the power and telephone lines.

The creeks and ditches around Carmel flooded the town on March 25. Residents reportedly rowed boats through the streets that day. The interurban bridge just north of town was washed out, as were many bridges across the state, leaving Carmel and numerous other towns isolated.

The water began to recede on March 26, but the storm was relentless. That night, the rain turned to sleet and snow as the temperature dropped below freezing. On the fifth day, the sun finally broke through the clouds, and the telephone and power lines were restored. The interurban resumed freight and passenger services to Carmel on April 1. It was a great relief to residents, who were desperate for news and supplies. It was almost another full week before the Monon resumed service.

The people of this area were resilient and immediately began to clean up and rebuild. I imagine we will see the same in the weeks ahead as our community comes together in the aftermath of the worst flood in our history.

You asked, and we listened! A favorite poster hanging in the museum is now available as a reproduction in our gift shop....
08/12/2026

You asked, and we listened! A favorite poster hanging in the museum is now available as a reproduction in our gift shop.

Originally created in 1987 to celebrate Carmel’s 150th anniversary, the poster offers a snapshot of the community at the time, featuring Carmel’s streets and local businesses.

Take a piece of Carmel history home with you! Reproductions are 24" × 36" and available in the museum gift shop for $30.

From our I Grew Up in Carmel series: Meet Bart Burrell on August 20! 🏀📚Carmel community, we have a very special homecomi...
08/12/2026

From our I Grew Up in Carmel series: Meet Bart Burrell on August 20! 🏀📚

Carmel community, we have a very special homecoming event you won’t want to miss.

On Thursday, August 20 at 2:00 PM, join us here at the museum to welcome back hometown legend Bart Burrell! Many lifelong residents remember Bart as a standout leader on Carmel High School’s 1977 State Championship basketball team before he went on to become an all-time great wide receiver for Purdue University.

But Bart’s most incredible victory didn’t happen on a sports field.

Come hear Bart share his jaw-dropping, inspiring story chronicled in his book, Bart’s Heart. After facing a terminal rare diagnosis at age 40, Bart defied all odds through a life-saving stem cell transplant—only to face an incredibly rare, combined heart and liver transplant fourteen years later.

Bart will be speaking about the mental discipline, faith, and community support that saw him through the ultimate fight for survival, followed by a Q&A and book signing.

🗓 When: Thursday, August 20 at 2:00 PM

📍 Where: Carmel Clay History Museum (211 1st St. SW)

🎟 Admission: Free/open to the public but advance registration is requested.

Register at carmelclayhistory.org

Come say hello to a true local legend and leave inspired. Books will be available for purchase at the event. See you there!

This table was FULL just a week ago! 😮Our commemorative anniversary shirts are selling fast!Celebrate America's 250th or...
07/01/2026

This table was FULL just a week ago! 😮

Our commemorative anniversary shirts are selling fast!

Celebrate America's 250th or the City of Carmel's 50th with one of our limited-run shirts. Stop by the museum on Thursday or Friday to grab yours and wear it to the parade on Saturday!

👕 Limited quantities remaining
💲 Just $20
Order online at https://carmelclayhistory.org/carmel-apparel/

Do you need a shirt to complete your Fourth of July outfit!? Our America's 250th and Carmel's 50th anniversary shirts ar...
06/26/2026

Do you need a shirt to complete your Fourth of July outfit!? Our America's 250th and Carmel's 50th anniversary shirts are selling fast! Visit the museum or order online before we run out! All shirts are $20. Visit https://cchmstore.square.site/s/order to place your order today.

Address

211 1st Street SW
Carmel, IN
46032

Telephone

+13178467117

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Carmel Clay History Museum posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Organization

Send a message to Carmel Clay History Museum:

Shortcuts

Share

Category