05/02/2026
🚨PLEASE READ🚨
We are aware of information currently circulating about the Local Study Commission and fire services in Butte-Silver Bow and want to ensure our community has accurate, reliable facts.
We understand this is a long read but the information must be shared.
If you have questions please reach out and we will be happy to help.
_________________________________________
Concern:
The Governor stated both sides should “sit down and work together” locally rather than involve the State.
Fact:
That is exactly what should happen, but meaningful collaboration requires engagement. Concerns have been raised about not having a voice, yet there has been little effort to engage directly with leadership to develop solutions.
Concern:
Option 2 is essentially HB 547 implemented locally.
Fact:
Local governments operating under a charter have the authority to organize and manage their own fire services when outlined in that charter. This is a local governance decision, not a state mandate.
Concern:
Montana Supreme Court precedent gives trustees authority over fire district services.
Fact:
Trustees have authority within their districts, but that does not override broader public safety responsibilities or coordinated emergency response systems. Public safety requires unified decision, making and consistent service delivery.
Concern:
Volunteers provide unique local knowledge that cannot be replaced.
Fact:
Career firefighters and other emergency responders also live and work within the community and bring both local knowledge and professional training. A unified system still utilizes local knowledge while improving coordination.
Concern:
Consolidation risks harming rural response times.
Fact:
Response effectiveness depends on staffing, training, and coordination, not fragmented governance. A unified system improves resource allocation and ensures consistent service standards across all areas.
Concern:
Current districts are active and functioning properly.
Fact:
Some districts have not held meetings, trainings, or maintained operational activity in years. In some cases, basic operational indicators, such as water usage, suggest stations may not be actively functioning.
Concern:
Public funds should continue to be distributed across all districts equally.
Fact:
Public funds must be tied to accountability and active service delivery. Allocating funding to non-operational or minimally active entities is not responsible stewardship of taxpayer dollars.
Concern:
The Director of Fire Services is overreaching authority.
Fact:
Fire service leadership roles across the state operate with defined authority to ensure coordination and effectiveness. The real issue is not authority overreach, it is the need to improve an inefficient and fragmented system.
Concern:
Current budgeting and accountability processes are sufficient.
Fact:
There is a lack of consistent budgeting, auditing, and reporting across districts. Requests for information have gone unanswered, and compliance with basic administrative expectations has been inconsistent.
Concern:
Departments are actively participating in oversight and coordination efforts.
Fact:
When asked to meet and review budgets under ordinance, only a small number of departments participated. This highlights a lack of consistent engagement and accountability.
Concern:
Volunteer departments significantly reduce costs compared to career staffing.
Fact:
Volunteer departments are valuable, but effectiveness depends on participation and response. Some districts have not responded to calls over extended periods, raising concerns about reliability and coverage.
Concern:
Volunteers may leave if governance changes.
Fact:
That concern is often overstated. Many volunteers serve their communities regardless of governance structure, and some have expressed concerns about the added responsibilities Option 1 would create.
FINAL TAKEAWAY
•Public safety requires accountability, consistency, and coordination
•Fragmented governance leads to inefficiencies and increased risk
•A unified system strengthens response, oversight, and service delivery
