11/11/2025
Statement on the Albany County Legislative Black Caucus’ Response
What the Legislative Black Caucus released is not a statement of progress, it is a performance of protection. This group has not meaningfully engaged with the organizations that have been advocating for change, oversight, and transparency at Albany County Correctional Facility. Since February, we have reached out for partnership and accountability, and what we have received in return are polite deflections and hollow words.
The most insulting part of their statement is the claim that the Sheriff has suffered “personal attacks.” The Sheriff went on his own page and publicly called us disingenuous and full of crap. We never attacked him personally. We raised concerns about abuse, neglect, and human rights violations inside the jail. If telling the truth about conditions that harm people is considered an attack, then the problem is not our language, it is their conscience.
Had Sheriff Apple met with us in January, when we received the first two complaints, instead of sending Inspector Prasner, who stood in front of us and lied repeatedly, this could have been resolved long ago. Instead, Prasner’s dishonesty and dismissiveness only made the situation worse. We kept receiving calls, we kept hearing from families in fear for their loved ones, and we kept being lied to by correctional staff.
Then to have the Chair of the Albany County Legislature, Joanne Cunningham, call us “difficult to work with” because we are asking for transparency and because we want the beatings to stop — that tells you everything. If being “difficult” means demanding that human beings not be brutalized, then we will continue to be difficult. Wanda Willingham, the co-chair of the Legislature, had to leave a facility tour because she was physically sickened by what she saw. But somehow, we are the problem.
And the Chair of the Black Caucus, Carolyn McLaughlin, has never once responded to a single one of our emails. Not one. They only reached out an hour before we were set to tape a CBS panel discussion. The meeting they scheduled took place the following Monday, before the show aired. It was nothing more than a performance, a meeting held so they could say they had met with the advocates. There has been no follow-up, no action, and no sign that they take these issues seriously.
How many beatings will it take before the caucus acts? How many more people must be shoved into cells and returned bruised, how many more officers must be allowed to act with impunity before elected leaders stop pointing fingers and start fixing the system? Marquis Norwood was brutally beaten at Albany County Correctional Facility and was one punch away from being another Robert Brooks or Messiah Nantwi. Will it take for someone to be beaten to death for them to finally take this seriously?
Taxpayers are already footing the bill for abuse. These are public dollars paying for brutality. Albany County has spent years writing settlement checks to victims of violence and misconduct inside the jail, and now taxpayers are about to fund yet another lawsuit because Albany County Correctional Officers went to Oneida County and brutally beat the incarcerated men and women there. The law firm Roth and Roth is taking the county to court, and once again the checkbook will show what the Black Caucus refuses to acknowledge — these are not allegations, they are patterns of abuse backed by evidence and payouts.
And how many legal visits will be denied because correctional staff and Superintendent Lyons do not want attorneys to see the bruises, the swollen faces, and the body blows on their clients? Every denial of access is another attempt to hide the violence and silence the truth. These are not isolated incidents, they are coordinated acts of cover-up.
While families call in fear for their loved ones, this caucus calls for patience. But patience is no longer an option. We cannot be patient while people are being beaten, silenced, and hidden away. We cannot be patient while officials lie to our faces and call it procedure.
The organizations advocating for change have done the work. We have documented the abuse, met with lawmakers, and pushed for reforms that bring real oversight and accountability. Yet those in power keep explaining what they cannot do instead of showing courage in what they must do.
The Black Caucus was created to serve the marginalized, not to echo the establishment. The people incarcerated at Albany County are their constituents too, and many have the right to vote. It may be time those votes reflect who truly stands with the people and who stands beside the Sheriff.
The group of organizations calling for oversight stands firm. There can be no progress without truth, no reform without accountability, and no justice without action.