21/08/2026
In 1993, Muhammad Sarfaraz was just 17 when he was arrested. Pakistan did not yet have legislation protecting children in conflict with the law, so his age never became a question the court was required to ask. In 1998, he was sentenced to hang.
Then, for the first time, Pakistan enacted a law for child offenders: the Juvenile Justice System Ordinance, passed in 2000. A presidential notification the following year said children sentenced to death, like Sarfaraz, would have their sentences reviewed. In 2008, an inquiry was finally ordered to determine whether Sarfaraz had been a minor at the time of his arrest. For a moment, it looked like his way out.
Instead, a court staff member misplaced his file. The one document that could have proven his age disappeared because of someone’s negligence. For four years, Sarfaraz sat on death row while no inquiry took place because there was no evidence left for age determination. When the missing file was finally noticed in 2012, the court did not reopen the case and instead stated that it was “no longer competent” to decide the matter. That administrative failure was enough to get his mercy appeal dismissed.
Years later, when a higher court ordered the file rebuilt, the system found a new way to fail him. The inquiry dismissed his juvenility claim over a school record, despite his family insisting Sarfaraz had never been to school. His case moved between courtrooms for months. When his lawyers tried one last appeal to the Supreme Court, prison officials blocked them from getting Sarfaraz’s signature on the power-of-attorney forms required to proceed.
On May 10, 2016, after 22 years on death row, Muhammad Sarfaraz was hanged. He was failed by a system that could not keep hold of his case file, and never gave him a real chance to be free from the sentence.
This is the second story in our campaign, documenting the cases of juveniles sentenced to death and executed in Pakistan. We tell Sarfaraz’s story to remember how a misplaced file became the reason he lost his childhood, and then his life.