23/04/2026
Today in a council meeting there was a review of New Year’s Eve celebrations and recommendations made for 2026/27.
Save Dunedin Live Music were disappointed to see the term "inappropriate music" thrown around with regularity in reference to some of Ōtepoti’s best up and coming bands.
As a group that has worked with council over several years to up-lift live music in this city, these comments feel like a great big backwards step.
On a personal level, I was proud to see our council platforming the bleeding edge of the youth music scene at a major event: something home-grown, political and unapologetically Ōtepoti.
Truly diverse community events have a wide range of styles – something for everyone –because not every band will be to everyone’s tastes. The DCC succeeded on NYE with a genuinely diverse range of styles, that resulted in a genuinely diverse crowd. Deciding that the youth music scene is ‘inappropriate’ for major events means that our council has decided that major events should not be welcoming to the young people of Ōtepoti. It is exclusionary and deeply disappointing, particularly given the responses that young people aged 15-17 wrote to councillors about how much they enjoyed the bands that night (read out by Cr Walker in an earlier meeting).
We were disheartened by the idea that council could find other “more appropriate” events where these bands could play. These comments are disrespectful, disconnected and reflects a longstanding disregard for the genuinely incredible music produced in this city.
We were also disappointed at the repeated assertion that a covers band needs to added to the event so that people can “dance to the bangers that they know the words to”, when in fact that is what happened at the event in question.
The awesome “Ōtepoti All Stars” are a cover band made up of local musicians, they are some of the hardest working cover musicians in Ōtepoti and they finished the night on NYE, playing songs that people know.
So why is the council discussing changes that have already been implemented?
The Otepoti all stars are a local band as well, so that is council money going to support local musicians at a council event - the way it should be - not sent out of town as some huge artist fee for a “Big Act”.
The event was well curated and representative of Ōtepoti/Dunedin, and that is something we can be proud of. I have never seen so many young faces and people from the music scene at a council event as there was at the 2025/26 NYE.
I believe we are experiencing disproportionate feedback due to the utterly underwhelming countdown experience negatively impacting perceptions of the whole event.
It is also disappointing to hear comparisons to NYE events in Queenstown and Timaru as though that is something that we should emulate. Our NYE is about our city, why would we want it to be the same as other cities?
After all, we have better music than they do.
(to this point I would implore the councillors to listen to “Play something we all know” that local surf-punk band Katharticus perform in response to this inane request)
Photo: Credit to Fraser from Dunedinsound.com for his always awesome Photography.