09/06/2026
Gideon Rachman (Financial Times):
"Nonetheless, Netanyahu insists that he is leading his nation to victory. In September at the UN, he boasted that Israel had “crushed” most of Hamas’s “terror machine”, “crippled” Hizbollah and “devastated” Iran’s nuclear and missile programmes.
But these claims look increasingly flimsy. Hamas is still in place in Gaza; Hizbollah is still a powerful force in Lebanon. The Islamic republic still has Iran in its grip and can still sow havoc with its missiles and drones.
In each case, Netanyahu made the same mistake. He chose to pursue an entirely military solution to Israel’s security problems — ignoring the political and diplomatic dimensions. As a result, he has mis-sold the tactical successes of Israeli military and intelligence — such as the killing of Hizbollah, Iranian and Hamas leaders — as proof that Israel is becoming more secure.
But, by now, it should be obvious: Israel cannot kill its way to security. If one group of leaders is assassinated in Gaza or Beirut or Tehran, others will emerge to replace them.
It is simpler — politically and intellectually — for Netanyahu to portray Israel’s enemies as mindless fanatics who can only be eliminated, rather than to engage with the underlying issues that are driving conflict. As a result, the Israelis refuse to consider that many Palestinians, Lebanese and Iranians are likely to respond in the same way to being bombed and killed that Israelis did to October 7 — not by surrendering but by fighting even harder."
The Israeli leader has tried to secure his country by entirely military means. It isn’t working.