27/09/2025
THE TIGHT, PRECARIOUS ROLE OF A LAWYER.
Dear Future Lawyers,
1. Scenario
Many times, as a lawyer, you will be approached by a client seeking your legal advice or opinion. That is normal, and this is exactly why you are training to become a lawyer. However, you will also encounter potential clients who approach you, speak with you, and at the same time tell you what to do and how to do it. The main challenge in this kind of situation is that the client's aims may not be supported by the law. The client might even offer attractive fees if you succeed in doing what they want based on the facts. What should you do?
2. The Challenge
The challenge in the above scenario is that, on one hand, a lawyer faces the choice of either agreeing with the client, providing sympathetic advice to retain the client and secure significant fees, or standing firm on the correct legal position despite the risk of losing the client, even when faced with financial pressures.
3. What will you be required to do in Such a Situation?
Remember, when called to the bar, you will swear to defend the law and the constitution. You must also recognise that you are not a comforter but a professional with a duty to advise in accordance with the law, not merely to give comforting advice. Such advice would be like giving paracetamol to a malaria patient.
Judge Ismail Hussain, State Counsel, in his book titled ‘Practical Drafting Skills for Law Professionals’ 2019, on page 2017, states the following regarding giving legal advice or opinions:
“Never disregard the law. Do not be tempted to tell the client what they want to hear when, in fact, the law does not support their position. A false impression of a successful outcome, when the law says otherwise, is negligent advice, and you are not of any assistance to your paying client. “
He goes on to state that;
“The purpose of an opinion is to provide advice to a client. It is also important to understand your role as a lawyer. You are to present an opinion that is dispassionate and objective. It is not your role to present an opinion that will please the client or advocate an outcome desired by your client. If, on the facts presented to you, you conclude that the course of action desired by the client is not permitted in law, then say so.”
4. Conclusion
In your journey as a lawyer, you will encounter clients who demand specific actions, sometimes promising high fees, even if these actions conflict with legal standards. You will need to navigate the tension between satisfying the client and maintaining legal integrity. You must realise that your role as a professional is to provide advice rooted in law, rather than simply offering comforting or sympathetic opinions. The purpose of legal advice is to give impartial and objective guidance rather than tailoring opinions to please clients. This approach will help you avoid negligent advice and uphold professional responsibility.