28/05/2026
PARASHAT BEHA'ALOTCHA: ONE ARK, OR TWO?
We read in parashat Beha'alotcha:
"They traveled a distance of three days from the mountain of HaShem. The Ark of HaShem’s Covenant traveled at a distance of three days ahead of them, to prepare for them a place to settle." (Numbers 10:33)
Rashi explains: "The Ark of HaShem’s Covenant traveled at a distance of three days ahead of them. This was the Ark that went out with them to war, in which were placed the broken pieces of the first set of tablets. It preceded them a distance of three days to prepare a suitable place for them to camp."
Was this the same Ark that the sons of Kehat of the tribe of Levi were assigned to carry from encampment to encampment, covered with a blanket of techelet (blue) dyed wool and a tachash skin, which resided permanently within the Holy of Holies?
Or was this, as some of our sages have postulated, a second Ark?
We are told in the book of Exodus that the master craftsman, Betzalel built the golden Ark of the Covenant.
And yet, in the book of Deuteronomy, Moshe, himself, says:
"At that time, HaShem said to me, 'Hew for yourself two stone tablets like the first ones and come up to Me onto the mountain, and make for yourself a wooden Ark, And I shall inscribe on the tablets the words that were upon the first tablets which you shattered and you shall place them into the Ark. So I made an ark of acacia wood, and I hewed two stone tablets like the first ones, and I ascended the mountain, with the two tablets in my hand.' And He inscribed on the tablets, like the first writing, the Ten Commandments, which HaShem had spoken to you on the mountain, from the midst of the fire, on the day of the assembly, and HaShem gave them to me. And I turned and came down from the mountain, and placed the tablets in the Ark which I had made, and there they were, as HaShem had commanded me." (Deuteronomy 10:1-5)
This Ark is described as a simple wooden box, with no elements of gold. Were there, in fact, two distinct Arks of the Covenant within the Israelite encampment? One, fashioned by Betzalel, made of acacia wood and gold, which never left the Holy of Holies except when it was being transported by the Levites across the wilderness, and a second, simpler Ark, made of wood only, constructed by Moshe, which is the Ark being referred to as having "traveled at a distance of three days ahead of" the Israelite to scout out a proper camp site?
Some sages certainly think so, adding further that clearly, as stated above, the Ark of Moshe contained the second set of tablets of the Law, while the Ark made by Betzalel contained the first set of broken Tablets.
We are further told in Numbers that, following the sin of the spies, when a breakaway faction tired to take on the Amalekites by themselves, that:
"They defiantly ascended to the mountain top, but the Ark of the Covenant of HaShem and Moshe did not move from the camp." (Numbers 14:45)
That is, the Ark that would be carried into warfare to guarantee an Israelite victory did not accompany them, thereby sealing their doom. Was this the Ark of the Covenant of HaShem that Moshe made?
Later in the book of Numbers that Ark did, if fact, accompany Israel to battle against the Midianites:
"Moshe sent them the thousand from each tribe to the army, them along with Pinchas the son of Eleazar the kohen to the army, with the sacred utensils and the trumpets for sounding in his possession." (Numbers 31:6)
The "sacred utensils" all our sages agree, included the Ark of the Covenant. Yet, Israel was in camp and not traveling. Therefore the golden Ark made by Betzalel would have remained in the Holy of Holies. The Ark that went to war would seemingly be the Ark made by Moshe.
While some sages opine that there were, in fact, two Arks, (and one opinion holds that there were three Arks!), others insist that there was but one Ark. Their opinion would seem to be bolstered by the story told in the book of I Samuel, which took place hundreds of years after Israel entered Canaan, in which the Ark of the Covenant was taken from the Tabernacle in Shiloh and brought to war against the Philistines, who captured the Ark. This Ark, which was eventually returned to Israel after it wreaked havoc for the Philistines, and was later brought by King David to Jerusalem, is definitely the golden Ark made by Betzalel.
The Ark of the Covenant, the most sacred of all the Temple vessels, which went missing sometime during the era of the first Temple, and whose trail has long vanished, inspiring many leads and legends as to its whereabouts, leaves us with many, many mysteries. Yet it should hardly surprise us that something so holy and unearthly should confound our ultimately limited understanding of G-d's works.