03/09/2026
Delays to justice can make an already difficult system an endurance test for survivors of s*xual violence. In the case of child s*xual abuse, intentional delays by the defendants can even mean the perpetrator dies having never faced justice. Justice delayed is justice denied.
For Derek McCarthy, a survivor of abuse by members of the Spiritan Order at Rockwell College, a priest who abused him died and no criminal case was heard.
Derek has recently heard that the DPP has decided not to prosecute a second individual accused of abusing him as a child. For some survivors, ensuring justice is served is central to healing, which can be set back considerably when they cannot pursue a criminal conviction.
Data published last year under a Freedom of Information request showed that the prosecution rate for s*xual offences was just 33% between 2014-2024, with ‘insufficient evidence’ often being the reason. The DPP applies a high standard when deciding whether to prosecute and operates under the legal standard of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt in criminal cases. Thankfully, the data also showed that when cases are prosecuted, the defendant is convicted in over 3 out of 4 cases.
A decision not to prosecute does not mean that a survivor should not be believed. It does not mean that what they experienced did not happen. But as Derek said himself to the Irish Independent, “I am still numb. What message does this send to other victims?”
We want all survivors of child s*xual abuse to know that at Dublin R**e Crisis Centre, support is available. Whether accompaniment to court, support ahead of and after a trial or just finding out what taking a criminal or civil case might involve, we are here for you. It is never too late to get information, help and support. The National R**e Crisis Helpline, run by our trained counsellors, is open 24 hours a day at 1800 77 8888 and we are here to listen.
Thank you, Derek, for sharing your story.