28/05/2026
Good News for our Breed. We’ll post here our submission to the Amnesty debate, and to the 3 questions that HSI had asked;
We in the IDHS, unanimously want the terms of the Amnesty to continue, preferably on a permanent basis. It was our Council who originally proposed the first scheme, in particular through the work of Elizabeth Deane Cogan, and John Anthony Cogan (RIP) within HSI. It is poignant that one of the greatest internal advocates within HSI, for the scheme, was Dr. Jack Murphy.
The initial scheme which ran from 2016 to 2021, was envisaged to grant lifetime rights to Inspection for all foals born within those years, from Class 4 parentage. Unfortunately, in an underhanded way, this option was scuppered without the knowledge of those who had championed the Amnesty.
So to answer the three questions;
1. Should the current amnesty rule remain in place beyond 2026?
It Must. And we favour it becoming regularised within the Studbook Rules, so that special provision does not need to be visited every 3-5 years. At the very least, a 10 year renewal is the least that should be granted. To limit it to 3 years is not sufficient and since it was given for 5 years in 2016, then surely this is not a hard limit. Extending the terms, preferably permanently, would give certainty and predictability to the sector.
As to the why? There are a number of reasons;
Firstly, the Amnesty continues to be necessary because the conditions supporting the two past amnesties, have not changed. In an Endangered Herd such as the Irish Draught, we cannot have purebred stock denied the full consideration for equal status within the herd. Typically 40% of purebred stock have been born to at least one un-inspected parent, for each year of the past decade.
Secondly, and possibly even more importantly, the Class 4s continue to hold a reserve of the greatest genetic diversity within the herd. The value of these stallions and mares, and their ongoing potential in contributing to herd health dynamics, needs to be promoted rather than impeded. A failure to grant an extension of the terms of the amnesty, would be destructive in this regard.
It should also be added here, that the North American Society has continued to operate the amnesty without interruption, since 2016. We think this is commendable of them, but it disadvantages us and means that our purebred foals out of C4, have devalued status here. They can be bought cheaply, (maybe by a middleman) and imported into the US, and immediately be eligible for inspection as an adult. We do not have this available to us. This cannot be considered in any way, to match the previous claims by HSI, that a Harmonisation of studbooks exists across sister Societies for the herd. It highlights a discriminatory allowance to one group over another.
We expect to have at least equal favour to other breeders and owners elsewhere, from our state sponsored Studbook Holder which is HSI. This is the home of our breed. If anything there should be greater favour promoted here, for the sister societies to follow. We are still rightfully sore about the secret, covert Amnesty that was granted by HSI to the GB Society from around 2010. We will not continue to be the breeders that are disadvantaged.
Lastly, the Amnesty has in a surprising way, also facilitated a move towards greater numbers for inspections. Considering we are dealing with purebred animals of un-inspected parentage, and a legacy of disfavour towards inspections, the Amnesty has been successful in engaging breeders and owners to more readily bring out their stock for inspection. These legacy issues stemmed from a time when there was greater distrust of the Inspection Process. With a change in personnel in HSI, there has been a greater acceptance of the inspections. But the practical legacy of the turmoil of the previous administration, has resulted in a backlog of owners seeking inspections for their mares. This year all the inspection sites were over-prescribed and there were not enough slots for all eligible mares to be inspected. We feel that the Amnesty also needs to be extended to accommodate the inspections of these mares who could not get an inspection slot. There needs to be greater capacity to handle more numbers.
2. What impact has the amnesty had on your members, and the Irish Draught Horse population since its extension in 2024?
The impact is twofold. It has supported breeders and given those who have bred such foals, greater freedom and success in marketing these offspring. But the term limit for the scheme, undermines all this. Foals born to C4 parentage during the years of the scheme are still undervalued because there is no certainty that they will be eligible for inspection in the future.
In terms of Genetic Diversity, it has allowed genetically valuable stallions and mares, to have their stock be considered for full status. This means that their genes are more likely to contribute to the herd. This is necessary in an endangered herd dominated by three over-balanced branches within three of the seven Foundation lines. The other four have almost fully been extinguished, but for a number of the Class 4 stallions. So these need to be accommodated to ensure their genes are added to the herd.
3. Are there any suggested amendments or improvements to the amnesty rule to better serve breeders and maintain studbook integrity?
The best way to help the breeders, is to help the breed. And the best way to help the breed is to give every purebred animal equal rights within the studbook. Our position is that all foals born within the years of any of these schemes should be eligible for inspection through their lifespan. Of course, there would be no need for all this if these terms were regularised permanently within the Studbook, and we did not have to keep revisiting these matters, and we could forge ahead with certainty.
https://www.horsesportireland.ie/hsi-to-recommend-continuation-of-the-irish-draught-amnesty-following-industry-consultation/?fbclid=IwdGRzaASDy-ljbGNrBIPKxGV4dG4DYWVtAjExAHNydGMGYXBwX2lkDDM1MDY4NTUzMTcyOAABHqAhWDi7w2WxvQoHJV7XZyCu13_l0c1OQYxh7trcGopwwPO4RvcxmFVk_O-L_aem_96sFeIkXrRVfVnJNFDkCBg&sfnsn=wa
Horse Sport Ireland (HSI) has confirmed that it will recommend the continuation of the Irish Draught Horse inspection amnesty rule...