18/05/2026
Gerry Burke has always been helping Strachur and District History Society, research behind the scenes and comes up with the information we need many times.
Posting this great piece of research on his behalf -
My comment on the previous post re. mysterious Rev Alexander McLaine begs questions I still can't answer but the earliest recorded minister to the parish surely deserves more than a fleeting ref. in the Church of Scotland's official pulpit personnel register.
God only knows what brought him from his native isle of Mull to Strachur in "enemy" Campbell territory where, in 1652, there was no manse and the old kirk of "Kilmaglais" was a ruin.
A member of the "rebel" Lochbuie MacLean sept he'd graduated (M.A) from Edinburgh university six years earlier and, initially, took up the charge of Kilbride in Arran where his predecessor appears to have had Jacobite sympathies and a fondness for drink. McLaine didn't last long for some reason and some of the elders of Strachur and Strathlachlan were also unhappy with him initially.
He appears to have settled down but, while the Argyll Synod was happy with his translation of some of the scriptures into gaelic, Dunoon presbytery had to reinforce his efforts with domestic parish "discipline" issues..
It's unclear from scrawled minutes of the time where he lived and preached but he was deprived of his ministry by an act of parliament in 1662 for defying the return of Scottish episcopacy.
He appears then to have returned to an island in "McLaine" territory where he ministered, possibly unofficially for ten years, until he received an indulgence from the privy council and sailed south with his wife and family to replace another dissident minister on the Isle of Bute in the wake of the notorious witches' trials. At Kilchattan, he appears to have been censured for continuing the practice of husbands and wives being buried separately at ancient St Blane's chapel.
How and where his career ended I've no idea but two of his sons, John and Thomas literally followed in his footsteps to preach in his previous parishes in Cowal, Bute and Arran before moving to Ireland.
It was Thomas's son James who veered off the presbyterian track to seek his fortune in London as the "Gentleman Highwayman" on Hounslow Heath and Hyde Park. His inherent good manners and civility earned him the nickname among his celebrity stage and political victims. He was hanged at Tyburn in 1750 and some of his victims wept, apparently. His partner in crime William Plunkett was never caught. His brother Archibald inherited the family vocation as a renowned presbyterian minister and scholar in the Netherlands.
PS: The 1999 fictionalised comedy movie Plunkett and MacLeane starred Jonny Lee Miller as McLaine and Robert Carlyle as Plunkett.