08/06/2026
“If college students can’t learn that well when there’s a computer in front of them, how do we expect eight-year-olds to do it?”
The million dollar question from Jonathan Haidt as he explains ‘Why You Should Be a Techno-Sceptic’.
When we have one-to-one device policies in schools with internet-enabled devices on every child’s desk, what exactly are we giving them?
A learning tool?
Or a device that can also provide access to games, videos, messaging, social media, YouTube Shorts and even po*******hy?
In his TED Talk, Haidt argues that we have normalised one-to-one devices in schools without properly considering the consequences for attention, learning and child development.
He points to clear scientific evidence from Sweden’s renowned Karolinska Institute - that computers in schools impair rather than enhance student learning.
And that a growing number of educators are becoming concerned about the impact of screens on concentration.
As Haidt puts it:
“Computers and tablets are multifunction entertainment systems.”
If adults struggle to resist notifications, multitasking and the pull of the internet, why do we assume children can successfully navigate the same distractions throughout the school day?
After years of leading the world in classroom digitisation, Sweden is moving back towards textbooks, handwriting and reduced screen use as concerns about learning outcomes have grown.
Yet the UK continues to invest heavily in EdTech and one-to-one device programmes.
Before we place a connected device on every child’s desk, shouldn’t we first ask whether it improves learning and what children may be losing in the process?
If you’d like to join the conversation around screens in education, join the Safe Screens WhatsApp community via the link in our bio.