04/09/2026
**updated with IJB meeting link**
So, why Insch?
That is the simple question the community deserves an answer to.
Turriff Community Hospital is 131 years old, older than Insch - and has many of the same challenges, including narrow corridors. Yet it remains open and is being upgraded, with around £250,000 invested in Turriff over the last three years.
Then there is Huntly’s Jubilee Hospital, which opened in 1889 and is now 137 years old. It too has received significant investment, with around £1.2 million spent across the site.
Yet Insch’s 104 year.old War Memorial Hospital, built through the generosity of its community as a lasting memorial to those who fell in the First World War, has now been formally closed.
And let's not forget the history of community investment in Insch Hospital.
The original hospital was built because the people of Insch and the surrounding communities wanted to create a lasting memorial. Money was raised, mainly through public subscription.
The hospital opened in August 1922 as a War Memorial Hospital, providing medical, surgical and maternity services.
The community continued to invest in its hospital. In 1972, a day room was added using funds raised by the local community, and in 1993 the Friends of Insch Hospital contributed towards another extension.
This is a hospital that the community has supported, funded and invested in for generations.
Nearly £500,000 has been raised by The Friends towards refurbishing and developing the hospital, with a commitment to continue fundraising to meet whatever further funding was required.
That offer was ignored and wasn't even mentioned at the IJB meeting.
The Friends offered to fund a 12 bed extension and refurbishment of the existing building, with a commitment to continue fundraising to meet whatever further funding was required.
So, if the Friends were willing to raise the money and continue fundraising, why wasn't that option properly considered?
And where does that leave the IJB Board and the local councillors who sit on it?
They have a responsibility to represent their communities and to scrutinise decisions that effect local services.
What questions were asked on behalf of Insch?
What challenge was made to the decision to close the hospital?
And why wasn't the Friends offer given the consideration it deserved?
This has been a six year process, during which the community has repeatedly been asked for its views through the SNA and again through the more recent survey.
The community took the time to respond, share its concerns and put forward alternatives.
After six years of consultation and engagement, there must now be accountability for the flawed process, the decisions that have been made and the alternatives that were put forward.
Why was investment available to maintain, upgrade and develop other community hospitals, but not Insch?
If community and intermediate care are genuinely the future, why wasn't Insch given the opportunity to be modernised, extended or developed?
Why is an older building in Turriff considered worth investing in, and an even older hospital in Huntly considered worth maintaining and developing, while Insch was closed?
We are not asking for special treatment.
We are asking for fair treatment, accountability, a proper comparison and a clear explanation of why Insch was treated differently.
The community has done its part, attendding countless meetings, engaging throughout the six year process, responding to consultations, completing surveys, raised funds and put forward alternatives.
Now it is only fair that the community gets answers in return.
The hospital may now be closed, but the questions remain.
The community deserves answers.
NHS Grampian
The Press and Journal Aberdeenshire Health & Social Care Partnership - AHSCP
Aberdeenshire Council
Moray Grant - SNP Cllr for West Garioch
Gordon and Buchan Conservatives - Cllr Sam Payne
Councillor Hazel Smith for West Garioch
Cllr Ross Cassie
David Keating for Inverurie
Councillor Gordon lang - Turriff and district ward
Councillor Anne Stirling, Turriff & District
Friends of Insch Hospital and Community SCIO
Evening Express
IJB meeting link: ffwd to 29.30 Prt 1, cont Prt 2
This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data.