21/06/2026
π If I were a member of the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Board tomorrow, these are the questions I would be asking before voting on Helensburgh.
The Board papers recommend ending 24 hour wholetime crewing at Helensburgh Fire Station and replacing it with a Day Shift Duty System supported by on call firefighters outwith weekday daytime hours.
Before supporting that recommendation, I would want clear answers to a few straightforward questions:
β What evidence demonstrates that on call availability in Helensburgh can reliably replace wholetime availability overnight and at weekends?
β If the future model depends on additional on call capacity, why is the recommendation being made before that capacity has been secured?
β If concerns about Faslane, Coulport and other high risk sites have been acknowledged, what evidence demonstrates that existing mitigations are sufficient?
β If the proposal releases around Β£693,000 of annual resource capacity, how can the Board demonstrate that the decision is being driven by risk and demand rather than financial considerations?
β Why is Livingston repeatedly used as a comparison when Livingston retains a wholetime appliance available 24 hours a day?
β Why should consultation responses not be published before a final decision is taken?
These are not political questions.
They are governance questions.
Tomorrow, Board members will decide whether a community that has had 24 hour wholetime fire cover since 1975 should lose that protection.
Whatever decision is made, the public deserves to know that these questions have been properly examined and answered.
π Board papers: Link in Comment 1
π₯ Public access to the Board Meeting : Link in Comment 2
π Every vote carries responsibility.
β³ Every vote carries accountability.