11/10/2026
The Star Hotel will resonate with many Crieff residents, once run by Charles MacDonald, a
well-known and respected proprietor at the time. He married Mary Comrie from Muthill, and the two resided at the Star Hotel raising three daughters and a son.
Their son Charles before enlisting with the 1st Battalion Gordon Highlanders in September of
1914, was employed as a fishmonger in London.
Charles was reported missing in action on the 14th Dec 1914, in an ill-fated attack on German positions at Wytschaete, Western Belgium.
When the 1st Battalion Gordon Highlanders with the 2nd Battalion Royal Scots advanced, they
immediately came under heavy r***e and machine-gun fire over sodden ground and incurred many casualties in the attack. Charles MacDonald Snr received a letter from a member of the Canadian Expeditionary Force just over a year later dated 21st Dec 1915 which read:
“Dear Friend, – I beg to inform you of the finding of a body which I believe to be your son – Private C. MacDonald No. 2383, 3rd Gordon Highlanders. I have handed his pay-book, containing his will, to my officer, who will see it handed over to the right quarter… Enclosed you will find a letter which I found in his pocket. It may be of some interest to you. I did all I could for him, and put him in a decent grave. Along with him were others of his comrades. They were lying between our trenches and the Germans’. How we came across him, the morning was very foggy, and of course made us invisible to the enemy, which gave us every opportunity to do what we had to do. To all appearances he died a painless death, and also a true British hero – one that yourself and the rest of your family may well feel proud of.”
Charles’ mother Mary died at the Star Hotel on 28th October 1918, of complications of influenza and bronchitis, aged fifty-four. Charles Snr also passed away at the hotel on 13th June 1926, both surviving their only son.
The MacDonald family were one of the first families in Crieff to have suffered a war
bereavement. Lance Corporal MacDonald is remembered on Mary’s headstone in Crieff
Cemetery, the Ypres (Menin Gate) Memorial in Belgium, and the Crieff War Memorial.
He was only 21 years old.
Lest We Forget.
Sources:
Morrison's Academy Archive
British Newspaper Archive
Andrew Scobie: Broken Columns