21/08/2026
In August 2021, Hugh had a CT scan. This photo was taken the following day. The scan wasn’t clear. The imaging was fuzzy.
What we now know is that Hugh had already relapsed at the time of that scan. By the time this picture was taken, the disease had returned.
Hugh had a high-risk cancer with a significant risk of relapse. Yet despite the imaging being inconclusive, we were never offered the opportunity to rescan him within a short timeframe, with the uncertainty, risks and options properly explained to us.
Had we been given that choice, we would have rescanned Hugh.
Six weeks later, Hugh died.
I’m not saying an earlier scan would have saved Hugh’s life. It wouldn’t have. But it may have given us longer with him.
Had we known his cancer had returned, decisions could have been made differently. Treatment options could have been considered sooner. And perhaps most importantly, we would have known just how precious and short the time we had left with our son was.
Those extra days or weeks would have meant everything to us.
This isn’t about parents overriding doctors or making clinical decisions themselves. It is about shared decision-making when there is uncertainty.
The principle already exists within the NHS: clinical expertise about the options, risks and benefits should be brought together with the circumstances and preferences of the patient and their family.
That is why, working with our MP Chris Hinchliff MP, we have tabled an amendment to the Health Bill to ensure that when imaging is inconclusive in a child at significant risk of relapse, parents are given the options and involved in what happens next.
If a scan is inconclusive, tell the parents. Explain what is uncertain. Explain the risks of waiting. Explain whether rescanning sooner is an option.
Then make that decision with the family.
We weren’t given that opportunity with Hugh. Nothing will give us those weeks back.
But Hugh’s experience can change what happens for the next child and the next family.
Parents deserve to know the options. And they deserve a voice in the decision. The right to choose.